by Jared Essig © October 04 2021, last modified.
This article is a draft.
Yoga is a technique for stilling the movements of the mind.1
It is a method whose proper goal is liberation (kaivalya).2 Physical and psychic powers may come as a result of practice3, but are often sought as the goal instead of as a mere means, and thus they often bring bondage and enmesh the practitioner in suffering, instead of assisting in liberation.
"It is good for a man to bear the yoke in his youth, let him sit and be silent, for the LORD has laid it upon him." — Lamentations 3
The techne of raja yoga taught here in my commentary on Patanjali's Yoga Sutras, will help you break the yoke of the selfish inclination[^id], and take on the yoke of the kingdom of heaven.
Yoga is bondage or it is freedom depending on who your king is. Like any art or techne, it can be used or misused for both good and evil. SanYoga is the bad yoga, the yokes that we must to break to the avidya (ignorance, for example: idolatry, materialism, atheism, prejudice) that keeps us in bound in knots of affliction and enthralled in oppressive systems of ideological control. ViYoga is the good yoga - the ability to discriminatively discern (viveka) and consciously choose.
"There are three yokes: The yoke of heaven (Torah), the yoke of kingship (Malchut, government service), the yoke of the way of the land (Derech Eretz). For him who takes on the yoke of heaven, the other yokes are lightened off of him." (paraphrase from the Talmud, citation needed)
"Take my yoke and learn from me, for I am gentle and lowly of spirit, and you will find rest for your souls, for my yoke is easy, and my burden is light." Joschka, according to Matthew, speaking about the yoke of the kingdom of heaven (c.f. Mark 12) talmud torah: discipleship in the law.
But let the practitioner be warned: kingship can be revoked through war, democratic revolution, or a higher authority. And not all kings are worthy of honor. In order to reach the goal of kaivalya, Raja yoga must be a path toward receiving the yoke of heaven. And not all heavenly bodies are worthy of worship. Not all kings are worthy of honor. Let the reader be warned.
Taking the King's Yoke
{{this section needs references}}
Find a clean, quiet, empty room with no idols, mirrors, or other distractions.
Pratyara, sensory withdrawal, is the 5th limb of the Ashtanga. Close your eyes, and soon your body will naturally stop moving.
Pranayama, restraint of the breath, is the 4th limb.
Asana is posture that is steady and comfortable, the 3rd limb - sthira sukha asanam.
Together these comprise hatha yoga, which although not our goal, is a preparation for higher practice. A healthy body is necessary in order to sit still for meditation or study, without the distraction of aches and pains. When we serve and worship, we should do so with healthy minds and bodies to offer as "living sacrifices, holy to Gd, and acceptable, this is our reason-based service/worship" described by the apostle Paul in his letter to the Romans 12:1-3. When David was hiding from King Saul and exiled from the tabernacle, he said, "let the lifting of my hands be as the afternoon sacrifice, the prayer of my lips be as sweet smelling incense."*
Patanjali in Yoga Sutra I.24 describes divine service as Ishvara pranidana"
Ishvara Pranidhana: Service of the Most High
Isvara is the supreme, distinct purusha (the great spirit), which is subject to no kleshas (afflictions), karmas (actions), consequences, or inner impressions left by desires (covetousness).4
{{This section needs references}} I hold this philosophic description of the Great Spirit to be consistent with the Hebrew conception of "El Elyon, the most high", and with Aristotle's conception of the "Unmoved Mover"; each is described in the attribute of number as exactly one. The attribute of omnipotence is not ascribed Isvara within the Yoga Sutras, but is not inconsistent with the description either. If we receive the book of Genesis as reliable testimony (and I hold it to be more reliable than the Vedas) then "El Elyon" was known to Abraham as "El Shaddai, the Almighty". When he blessed the sons of Keturah and "sent them away toward the East", he "gave them gifts". The talmud infers that these gifts were names of the most high which could be uttered while in a state of impurity, such as "Ram" (exalted), or Ishvara. The bnei qedem. See below: [Raja Yoga Relation to Abrahamic faith and Judaism](/raja-yoga#relation-to-abrahamic-faith]
The downward progression into the spiritual darkness of polytheism begins with personify each attribute with mythological stories and idols, and thus separating them from each other and from their source. Yoga darsana describes Ishvara as Purusha, as spiritual and invisible, and not as embodied in prakriti. See below: Raja Yoga Relation to Hindu Polytheism, Buddhist Idealism, and Advaita Vedanta
Pratyahara: Sensory Withdrawal
{{expand section}} {{This section needs references}} Withdraw the senses (pratyahara) and focus awareness on a single point (drishti) - I suggest focusing on the luz bone between the shoulderblades or on tailbone, but not on one of these to the exclusion of the other. Some teachers have students focus on the breath, but a better focus is on the solar plexus. It could be on any single point within the body, until the mind becomes still and single-pointed (ekragata), concentration (dhyana) becomes possible and even easy.
Sadhana: התמידה, Daily Practice
Practice this daily for several years when waking and again when laying down to sleep, in order to purify the imagination, restore the body image, and to recover buried memories. See below: Svadhyaya
Yoga is the stilling of the turnings of the mind. - yoga chitta vritti nirodhah
When the heart/mind is stilled, the intellect can awaken.
Dhyana and Dharana : Concentration & Meditation
{{This section needs clarification and references}}
A healthy body is necessary for a healthy mind. The yogic anthropology calls mental "thought" the "chitta", and locates it in the heart; yoga aligns with torah anthropology in this respect, which refers to the mind/heart as "lev". When the turnings - the vritti - the unnecessary modifications - of the heart are stilled that heart rate can be slowed or hastened at will. Thus the yoga practioner's heart/mind and body come under the authority of his intellect. Among karmis - people who are pursuing experiences and experiencing drama - this order is reversed, and their minds are driven by bodily compulsions and the intellects given over to prejudice and ignorance. Midrash koheleth 5:2 also teaches this principle in regard to the tsadikkim. With the senses withdrawn, body steady and comfortable, the breath deepened, the mind still and single pointed, and the intellect awakened, we can choose an object of concentration and by directing an continuous flow toward that object, the intellect becomes fixated (dharana), and the object begins to reveal its secrets. The ability to enter meditation may take years of practice and purification of the body and the imagination, for people who have acquired much karma and have become bound in many kleshas. For others, the ability may seem to come naturally and require very little preparation.
The meditative object chosen may be gross, subtle, or conceptual. First, choose to concentrate in turn on the ethical restraints - the yamas - which form the connection between ourselves and other selves.
Yamas: אסורות, Restraints, Ethics
{{expand section}} {{This section needs references}}
- Satya, truthfulness
- Ahimsa, non-violence
- Asteya, non-stealing
- Brahmacarya, sexual purity, marital fidelity, restraint and focusing of creative power.
- Aparigraha, non-covetousness, non-hoarding.
"Who is wise among you, and endued with knowledge? Let him shew out of a good conversation his works with meekness of wisdom. But if ye have bitter envying and strife in your hearts, glory not, and lie not against the truth. This wisdom descendeth not from above, but is eartly, sensual, demonic. For where envying and strife is, there is confusion and every evil work. But the wisdom that is from above is firt pure, then peaceable, gentle, and easily entreated, full of mercy and good fruits, without partiality, and without hypocrisy. And the fruit of righteousness is sown in peace by them that make peace." - Epistle of Jakobos (James, Yaakov) 4:13-18
The snake worship of southern India, reflected in the so called "kundalini yoga" brought to the west by yogi Bhajan and others, had ancient counterparts in the "ourouborous" cults of the caananite and other near eastern religion. Perhaps this is what James had in mind in warning against the "wisdom from below".
Asana: Steady and comfortable posture
Upon Waking
{{expand section}}
Morning Routine (Shacharit)
-
tadasana mountain (create a pranic samskara that will be used for vinyasa in the following sequences)
-
tadasana, trikonasana left triangle. utthita trikonasana, inverted triangle (hold for three breaths), trikonasana, tadasana. Repeat on the other side. Address a blessing to the creator and sustainer, "I graciously thank you, living and eternal king, who straightens the bent."
Early morning, an hour or two before sunrise is the best time to practice. When finished, sit in meditation in a sukhasana, easy sitting pose, or dandasana - staff pose, or any other seated pose that is steady and comfortable. -
shacharit namaskara. Saluting the dawn. I graciously thank you, living and eternal king, who created the great lights: the sun to rule by day, the moon to rule by night, and who created the stars." (This is a better practice than "saluting the sun" with surya namaskara, because the sun can be miscontrued as an independent power worthy of worship, whereas the dawn is known to be temporary and fleeting, and is less likely to be personified and worshiped by ignorant idolaters. For this reason, it is better to not practice sequence of bowing before the dawn while in public, unless a blessing is recited in the common language of the land in order to remove all doubt.)
-
optional warrior sequences, as needed and as appropriate to your level of practice. (for examples: virabhadrasana II left warrior, tadasana, virabhdrasana II, right warrior.) Precise performance of asana is not as important, as the performance of it with the pranayamas cultivated in the first sequences: perform the sequence in vinyasa. Also very important: close the eyes while practicing, in order to maintain pratyahara. Focus the drishti of the inner eye on those joints that are stressed, and on those muscles that are flexed or stretched. This is neglected in most studio teaching, and is better practiced alone than in a group.)
Address a blessing to the creator and ruler of all flesh: "I graciously thank you, living and eternal king, who girds Israel with strength and teaches his people discipline."
Afternoon Routine (Mincha)
{{expand section}}
Bedtime Routine
{{expand section}}
Svadhyaya: Analytic Study
of ones own body, ones soul, and authoritative texts. See also: Lunatic Mental Health
By purifying the intellect (buddhi) from materialism (avidya) and the other kleshas for which it is the productive field.
We should ceease operating from superstition and delusions. Having perfected the yogic or philosophic method, we can make use of our rational nature (pramana), by means of which propositions about world can be understood and tested, on three proofs, or epistemological bases: direct perception, logical inference, and reliable testimony.
Samkhya Physics and Metaphysics
Yoga darsana assumes ontology and metaphysics of Samkhya darsana, which is roughly consistent with Aristotelian hylomorphism. In short, the external world is real, change is not an illusion, but there is a universal, unchanging, invisible spiritual reality behind it (purusha).
The raw material of the perceptible world is prakriti, which is comprised of three gunas: tamas (matter, inertia), rajas (energy, kinesis), and satva (light, truth)
Relation to Hindu Polytheism, Buddhist Idealism, and Advaita Vedanta
(In my opinion, yoga darsana exists as an existential response to advaita vedanta, non-dualistic monism, which is the philosophic system underlying Hindu religion) and as a method of psychological recovery from its fatalism, which is itself a response to the magical thinking of hindu polytheism. All basic errors. Similarly in greek polytheism, "the fates" are essentially higher than the other gods, and neo-platonic monism is a parallel.
Sikh dharma seems to be a 16th century revival of Advaita Vedanta, manifested as religion. It may be a rectification of and improvement over Hinduism and Islam, and the food and hospitality is quite good, but its a basic philosophic error.
Yoga seeks to enlighten the buddhi (intellect) through stilling the chitta (mind), which enables scientific/episteme (pramana) knowledge of the external world and of man's spiritual nature (purusha)
Buddhism reduces humanity to pure intellect, denying the reality of the material world, it also denies the existence of the Great Spirit, Ishvara. It seeks to escape the errors of hindu polytheism through pure Advaita (non-dualism), but without the Vedantic myths and superstition. Its correct in its negative assessment of Vedanta, but it annhilates itself along with the false gods, a basic error. Also, they do not acknowledge the good, viewing physical life as pure suffering, another basic error. Against these various fatalisms, Yoga affirms that future suffering can be avoided. Samadhi Pada, I.16 (?)
Relation to Abrahamic faith and Judaism
c.f. Moshe Glazerson, "From Hinduism Back to Judaism" Bnei Keturah were probably the brahmins. The vedas are mostly Sanskrit of Indo-European origin, but certain key philosophic terms are of Semitic origin. For example, prana (pe'er, as in tiferet), drishti. (drasha, midrash)
Relation to Aristotelian Hylomorphic theory and Virtue Ethics
Yoga darsana's practice of examination (svadhyaya) and ethics (yamas) correspond roughly to Aristotelian ethics: the virtuous disposition can be taught, learned, and practiced, and future suffering can be avoided through living in harmony with natural law. (dharma)
Distance Yourself From an Evil Person
Kosher Yoga — letters to friends and beginners Recently, Alabama makes yoga legal in public schools. They adopted some of the "fences" I proposed, legislating that "chanting, mantras, mudras, mandalas, induction of hypnotic states, guided imagery, and namaste greetings shall be expressly prohibited." However, they did not prohibit idols or photographs/icons as objects of meditation, which are more problematic than mandalas. I see nothing wrong with the greeting Namaste "I do not steal your truth/your name": "Naam (name/truth) Asteya (yama principle of non-stealing)", as long as its not used to mean an uncritical acceptance of religious dogma.
My Story, Teachers, Ashrams and Commentary
In Los Angeles
I learned the philosophy of yoga along with various asanas of hatha yoga, from mystic strangers encountered by divine coincidence, while living outdoors on the beach. Here are a few of them:
- "Jammuna" who not only survives while living outdoors, but thrives and helps others. Nevertheless, he should stop consulting the dead, and probably ought to be home raising his own children.
- The Kirtan Rabbi, Andrew Hahn. Qi Gong. Although he didn't teach asana, he taught some rabbinic wisdom on healing and resurrection that informs every asana I do. I begged him to gift me his CD of recorded music, since I had no money to pay him, and he did, and I'll repay him someday with interest, like I pledged to do. He recites the tehillim, the psalms of David, in kirtan call-and-response style. I'm so glad I learned from him before I encountered the other bhaktis, with their beautiful and addictive, but also hypnotic and stupefying repetitions to demons and to gods that don't exist. His kirtan is also a more effective way for beginning students of Hebrew to learn the tehillim, than the manner of hyper-advanced recitation done in the synagogues.
- Savitri, who analyzed my physique and gave me the perfect asana to work on - fish pose, and who has physical intelligence and delicious cooking and a pretty smile. But like many germans, seems to have a profound misunderstanding of grace and moral responsibility, and an expectation that others are obliged to "forgive and forget," just because she forgave her grandfather. But I don't have the authority to forgive, and I will not forget. And this self-indulgent detachment from reality into mysticism, mythology, and "the guru's grace" is the same process that caused a generation to be destroyed. She was trying to moveupward into the bhakti hipsterscene and I was socially mobile in the downward direction, trying to help street people recover from addiction and learn derech eretz by working at DIY bike repair place. I tried to involve her in my practice of karma yoga, and she resented it. Thanks, and goodbye. Our brief friendship ended after I got more involved in activism when a youngster got shot by police. I hope she and I meet again after we both mature a little bit, and I'll try to be less contemptuous of the bourgeois.
- Natan Halevy, who saved me from the acrobats and gymnastic body cultists by teaching me the truest asana, and the purpose of sadhana. He taught to sit and practice daily morning Sadhana, and the most important sequence - that which leads to sitting in meditation. He tries to prevent his students in India from bowing to his photograph.
- The "6,000 year old" yogi living in the pickup truck who calls himself "godfather" whose grandiose flatteries and repeated insistent attempts cultic mind control I resisted, by refusing to call him "godfather", and refusing to learn meditation with him until he taught me hatha yoga. Once he got temporarily unstuck from his delusional fixations, he was able to teach me the essence of hatha yoga in 30 seconds, more than I ever learned at studios. We were camping out on the same street - skid rose and 3rd. He had plans to take over the world, with my help. He suspected me to be at least 2,000 years old, and told me that I was "that guy". Be careful, people. This stuff is effective, but dangerous.
- Fremont, escuela Bom Brio. Although Capoeira is not my goal, I do prefer dancing over fighting. Andthe street escuela was certainly better company than the dope fiends, gangsters, and knuckleheads of Venice dogtown; and better company than the spiritual gangsters of the petite-bourgeouis bhakti hipster scene. Esquiva and Negativo are useful asanas. Avoid headstands, as they can injure you, and practice handstands instead. Half moon pose and Warrior III, before cartwheels. If you're so agitated that you can't stop moving, use Qi Gong to slow it into sterotypic movements - also good for people with autism spectrum or tourette's syndrome. But don't forget: this is not a dance - it is a fight whose malice and cunning are disguised within dance. The immanent awareness of death's proximity has a way of inculcating the fear of the Eternal, which is the beginning of wisdom. Bencao, Bautizado.
- The muscle beach AcroYoga crew - they are practicing gymnastics and bhoga, not yoga. But its done gratis, outdoors, and no one is collecting money, and I had the opportunity to teach some students and thus repay my teachers by transmitting their lessons, and fulfill the vow of Asteya. For these reasons, it is a better value than most so-called "yoga studios", IMHO. They taught me a technique for handstands, which is very important. Most of the rest is unnecessary and probably a waste of time, unless your goal is cheerleading, fornication with cheerleaders, or seeking employment as a circus clown. This is merely a phase: don't get stuck in it.
- The "Minyan": This is where I learned pratyahara. They do it along with the "Shema", but without holding the posture nearly long enough, repeating the formula without actually practicing it. They should hold their eyes closed for at least ten or twenty minutes, and learn to recite their verses by memory. This is how vision is restored.
- The Karma Yogini of the Dharma Kitchen A certain kind, generous, and beautiful woman offered to pay for a month of practice at a studio, so I went to look for studios worth attending, unable to accept the idolatry in the ones she recommended. I sat on the sidewalks outside yoga studios, standing like a tree, and inquiring of students entering and exiting. I found the vast majority to be highly ignorant, and the studios complicit in this situation. Because I was poor and homeless my mere existence exposes, I suppose, the vacuity and impotence of their own practice. Admist the other books and merchandise, almost none sold copies the yoga sutras of Patanjali, and none held readings or practiced text study or svadhyaya. Only two had no idols and no mirrors, which was my baseline requirement, and of course they had the smartest students. The woman was a professional cook working with our "Occupy Venice" crew to start a dharma kitchen, out of compassion for the poor, and a real "karma yogi", a very rare individual. She owned a house and apparently needed a man to father her baby. I had the desire and ability to give her what our bodies wanted, and as a homeless man it is quite tempting to get indoors, but this is karma, not yoga. The thought of becoming a cool Venice hipster, "spiritual gangster", and casual idolater was almost more terrifying than thought of remaining a skid row derelict, so I did not pursue the job opportunity, tempting as it was. To be clear though, brahmacarya does not mean celibacy, it means sexual purity and directing creative energy. Marriage and fatherhood or motherhood should be a goal of yoga for most people. Bring children into the world and raise them to be righteous adults. Though she will remain nameless for now, I thank her for helping me find my path.
- Yoga Shala West is an ashtanga studio in the mysore tradition. It so happens that its only one that observes the principle of Asteya (non-stealing) in its membership/fee structure.
- [Yoga West]() opens the studio for daily sadhana from 4am-5am, gratis. I practice raja ashtanga, and work to bring down the prana, while the others all try to elevate their kundalini - a basic error IMHO. And I discovered later that Desikachar and other preceptors do as well. Kundalini is avidya. At 5am they start chanting Aquarian mantras in hypnotic repetitions, and I leave. As a person sleeping outdoors and eating in soup kitchens I take whatever help I can get, but even I have standards. But I wake early, and its nice to get inside and wash my face in the bathroom after waking. Starbucks opens at 5:30 and I hate the uptempo dancy music. There are dozens of synagogues nearby with morning prayers, often starting 20min before sunrise. They have bilingual copies of the prayerbook, and the information content is much higher than in the stupefying repetitions of the Aquarians in the kundalini cult, but they seem out of touch with the physical. Back at Yoga West, alot of the students go to the nearby Sikh gurdwara where they recite Guru Granth Sahib, the 16th Century devotional literature of the 10 gurus which constitutes their sacred scripture. Sikh Dharma seems to be basically a revivalist movement of Advaita Vedanta with a rejection of the Hindu pantheon and its idolatry. Thats why they ignore Patanjali, they consider yoga darsana "dualistic".
- The Sikh Gurudhwara
- Marcus Fried - yoga of the mouth, lips, and tongue. Very significant lesson, should be applied within every asana.
In Portland
None.
There is one ashtanga studio in NE Portland that studies the Yoga Sutras at 6am on Wednesday mornings, but its full of disgusting idols. Since it would violate my vow of "Satya" to give honor to this, I refused to pay the money. However I acknowledged the principle of "Asteya", and asked him to remove the idols so that I could pay him, or else allow me to attend the pranayama class and sutra study without paying. The Yogi accepted the second proposition, and said I could find another way to contribute.
References
- Patanjali (circa 2nd–4th cent. BCE). Yoga Sutras.
Dasgupta, Surendranath. Yoga as Philosophy and Religion. London: Kegan Paul, Trench, Trubner & Co. Ltd. reprinted unabridged by Dover, 2002. ISBN 0-486-42505-3
- Glazerzon, M. (1984). From Hinduism Back to Judaism. Himelsein Glazerson Publishers, Jerusalem
Notes
-
Patanjali, I.ii: "Yoga chitta vritti nirodha" Yoga is the restraint of the modifications of the mind-stuff. (Satchidananda) ↩
-
Kaivalya Pada, "The Portion on Liberation", Chapter 4, Patanjali. ↩
-
Vibhuti Pada, "The Portion on Attainments", Chapter 3, Patanjali. ↩
-
Patanjali, I.xxiv. (c.f. I.xxiii, II.i) ↩