by Jared Essig © September 03 2021, last modified.
From a letter sent 10 June 2020
See also: Shut The Fool Down
See also: Womens Lives Matter
Hello brothers, friends, boys, men, and allies everywhere:
When I was a boy, somewhere I absorbed various misogynistic notions that I expressed by describing the differences between boys and girls in terms like these: "boys are better than girls because boys have/do/can..... whereas girls don't/can't/lack .....". Another notion born of pride is "I don't need or want "friends" who are girls." "I'm not gonna ever fall in love or get married."
Although my desire to avoid girls naturally ended when adolesence brought out sexual desire, I never learned the basic skills of romance and courtship, and also the academic culture I wanted to assimilate to devalued marriage. What "successes" I had with women, if they can be called that, had more to do with the initiative of the women involved, and later with the macho posturing I adopted.
I deeply regret the pride, the illusion of self-sufficiency.
My sophomore year college I joined an all-male greek fraternity. The one I joined encouraged sexual exploitation of young women (as well as of the young pledges themselves). My full account of this will be published eventually. I was somewhat in denial of this. Also, the ancient academy of Plato devalued marriage and had a legacy of misogyny and homoeroticism. I didn't know about this, and there was not critical thinking about these things in my classes. Unless it is explicitly outlined and rejected, college students can find themselves assimilating to it without knowing it.
I have publicly renounced the dictum of membership in this fraternity and begun to call upon my alumni peers and active members to do the same and replace it with this:
Pledge: Health, Reason, and Virtue With physical health and mental awakeness comes the ability to practice virtue.
Men should learn skills of romance and courtship, and handling rejection so that they can have success in their relationships, treat women well. These problems emerge because there is a basic neglect of teaching from the older generation. To fill this void, men learn from theirs peers which can be good or bad depending on the value system of the peers. If virtue is not made a specific goal, and unless there are reasoning skills, the friendship will probably be bad. Male friendships accross age group is a good thing, and I support the idea of frats in general. Friendship based on virtue, the gathering of the righteous, is good for the friends and good for the world. That is what the boy scouts was designed around and what my pledge is designed to create, and why it may be interesting to you, even if youu aren't in a frat or even in college.
The misogynistic aspect of my frat consisted in mocking and delegitimizing womens' discourses and feminist groups, as if women don't have the right to defend themselves from male predations. Men who scoff at feminism but refuse to confront misogynists are either naive, cowardly, or exploiters themselves. I now hold that women can and should organize and work politically to defend themselves from organizations like my fraternity, as well as from con-men, pimps, and the seducers, "pick-up artists", and frat boys who imitate and draw tactics from them. Women are totally within their rights to denounce a "rape culture" and to subject these ideologies and organizations to public shame. Men should learn that misogyny is also bad for them. Men who demean women and make light of exploiting them sexually, deprive themselves of authentic friendship with women and mutually beneficial sexual partnership with healthy women. They impoverish themselves mentally and spiritually. They also exploit other men, financially, socially, and otherwise. And male victims of this become perpetrators of this. Frats, street gangs, and some companies use bribery and hazing rituals to normalize abhorrent practices and to create a perverse sense of "normal" so that the male initiate becomes psychologically stuck. Friendship based on vice, the congregation of the wicked, is bad for the friends and and bad for the world. Apart from social justice, rational self-interest is another reason to reject misogyny and stand up against expressions of it. Rather than mocking feminists, men should ally with them and actively work against it and help women defend themselves.
Therefore I urge my brothers to read the pledge I wrote, think about the principles outlined in it, and do a self-examination to remove the various dogmas of ignorant misogyny they may have absorbed from the surrounding culture, whether unconsciously or deliberately. Whatever the excesses and errors of radical feminism may be, it is a cowardly double standard to criticize them while remaining silent on the subject of misogyny and exploitation of women.
Even if they are not willing to re-examine their prejudices on this matter, they should know that I am ashamed of what I said and did in support of misogynistic social structures. I'm also ashamed that I was silent so long: I should have spoken out 20 years ago. Don't follow my example in this respect. Do please follow the example of humility and realistic moral reasoning, about this issue and also in general.
Actions have consequences. I have come to age 40 without having marriage or children. Speaking objectively, this is a basic failure to make stable social bonds. There is probably a connection between the sins of 20 years ago and the suffering I now experience. And I can think rationally to avoid it in the future. A man at age 70 with no children is not a happy man. And it gets harder with age to succeed and begetting offspring. Therefore the awareness of my own suffering and natural desire to avoid it in the future motivates me to do the work of self-examination, repentance and confession, to think rationally about means and ends, and to make better choices.
I'm not sharing this with you because I want to solicit your opinions about my life or problems. Please spare me. I don't trust your opinions unless you show basic competence and willingness to engage in moral reasoning about your own lives. There should also be compassion.
I describe this in order to make explicit what I mean terms like "moral reasoning" or "repentance". I've come to realize that for many post-christians the term "repentance" means something very different and almost antithetical, along the lines of a vague feeling of guilt, asking God for general pardon, and then going to church to sing some Jesus rock and hear a word of inspiration and trusting in forgiveness and indulgence. This isn't repentance, its magical thinking. Therefore it is necessary to define the terms clearly. Because that is almost antithetical to concept of "reasoning". In french, "penser" means "to think", and that is often precisely what is avoided in christian "re-pense-ance" The 12 step recovery groups are much closer to the biblical concept of repentance than the church is. And that is one reason why they are so much more popular - because it works.
I pray that in the merit of remorse, repentance, and true change that the "curse", if I may call it that, of sterility will be removed from our generation, and that we will succeed in being fruitful and multiplying and enjoying satisfaction in our partnerships with women.
Regards,