by Jared Essig © February 01 2021, last modified.

« 2020 Portland BLM/Antifa Uprising Is anti-zionism a form of ethnic prejudice and anti-semitism? A group of activists asking us to Boycott, Divest from, and Sanction Israel wants us to believe that no, it is not. Is Zionism an imperialist, colonial newcomer to the middle east? Is it a fascistic power that is oppressing minority groups around the world? The BDS groups wants us to believe that yes, it is.

Before attending this protest, I believed BDS was a way of non-violently demonstrating against Israeli security policies. The mischaracterization of Israeli Jews as "White European colonizers", the ignorance and distortion of historical facts, and the chants of "death to Israel" have convinced me that it is both violent and antisemitically racist. Please read this account and make up your own mind.

First, any activist who makes anti-fascism an organizing principle and works for human liberation of any kind, ought to start taking a moment to remember the 6 million Jews and X million others who were systematically murdered in the Nazi Genocide. And anyone who makes a claim to antifascism should join me, along with all other humanitarians in making this simple committment: NEVER AGAIN.

The Portland Intifada of 2020

Do you remember the month long seige on the federal courthouse during July? And the community kitchen known as "Riot Ribs", and the protest encampment in the Portland plaza blocks, lownsdale square? Many of us on the ground believed it was a spontaneous, anarchist led movement, because thats how we were actually operating and making decisions. (I organized the protest art tent, and like several other occupiers, and like most black protest leaders across the street at the Jail Courthouse, opposed the seige). But how the police-abolitionist group mind became progammed to strike the federal courthouse, which, of all institutions in American government, should instead be our closest ally in the civil rights struggles, it seemed that no one knew and no one really cared. They were moving with sheer momentum, not with planning or direction. They wouldn't listen to organizers on the ground, the group direction coalesced in private encrypted chats on Telegram and Signal, which I never joined. I never wore all black, so due to their security cultures I was excluded from operational conversations among the small affinity groups that form black blocs, that comprise the Antifa movement on the ground. Within these affinity groups, it seemed that there was no forethought, accountability, or self-reflection other than the dogmatic self-justification of all or nothing, us vs. them, good vs. evil thinking: "No good cops in a racist system, no bad protestors in a revolution".

The marked change that occured in July was the mob shifted its focus from attacking the Portland Police HQ, to attacking a federal installation and America itself. This is certainly consistent with the anarcho-communist ideologies that are held and proclaimed proudly by Antifa identifing groups and individuals. But the group mind was programmed and accelerated by a foreign organization.

Palestinian Day of Rage, July 1st 2020

Prior to any of this, the BLM and BDS groups in Portland invited Ms. Katbi-Smith to bring along the Portland DSA as a co-sponsor of the "Palestinian Day of Rage" event on July 1st in the amphitheater park. When she asked the working group and general assembly on our Slack platform, on which hundreds of members are active (though we have recently migrated to an open-source, self-hosted platform), if she could represent DSA, they almost all gave assent. Being a new member, I abstained.

The event began at a Lutheran church in NE, and after a car parade, the ended in the City Hall park amphitheatre, The tabled some propaganda, set up a PA, and the organizers began with this proclamation: "We are living on STOLEN LAND!" For the following month, "Stolen land, stolen people", was repeated by the group mind almost every night.\ I can't dispute either of these claims, and won't. Liberals don't want to confront reality, but it needs to be said. Most of us feel this way. Are you awake yet?

During the event, organizers asked local Palestinian individuals to come to the mike and "speak your rage". The told of the suffering of their lives and families, at the hands of the IDF or the police. Ms Katbi-Smith was one of the MCs inviting speakers, and she also "spoke her rage". I don't recall the details. Agitators filtered through the crowd sitting on the grass. The organizers led the following chants: "From the river to the sea, Palestine will be free!" I'm not sure how many people noticed, because it sounds aspirational and it feels good to say, but this is an explicit rejection of the two-state solution that was the basis of the now failed Oslo process. If this total rejection of Israel has been going on the whole time, it is a probably at least one reason why Oslo process failed. It is clear from this statement alone that the organizer don't want peace. They Israel to disappear; they want war.

They got us to stand. I stood, briefly. I thought about what it would be like to remove the Roman empire from the land of Canaan, now Israel, which the Romans had renamed Palestine, much like English settlers renamed turtle island "America". Like they had done in so many other lands, the Romans, after invading, colonizing, and eventually conquering the former kindgom of Judea, capturing Jerusalem and burning the temple in 70A.D., renamed the entire region, including Samaria, Galilee, and Idumea "Palestine", to spite the defeated Jews who still aspired to liberation and independence. The name Palestine was originally greek, and has always been a foreign, European imperial import. It may be related to the Philistim, a "sea people", probably of Greek origin, who had briefly settled in the Gaza strip after invading and being expelled from Egypt. These "Philistines", of whom Goliath is the most famous, after defeat by the first kings of Israel Saul and David, are not mentioned again in the hebrew books of kings or chronicles, nor in the prophets, nor by later historians, probably boarding their longboats and triremes and colonizing some other Mediterranean coast or island of which the Greek sea peoples colonized many. Herodotus, the Greek historian, is the first to name the region "Palestine", reflecting an ancient prejudice, but other than that he seems to have deliberately ignored the region in his geographic works, perhaps an act of deliberate ignorance. The Romans began using the term intermittently after Julius Caesar to refer to the land of Israel, perhaps because of Hellenic habits of thought, and perhaps as imperialist propaganda to delegitimize the indigenous nation of Judea, and lay claim to the land, reflecting Greco-roman colonial sovereignty.

"From the river to the sea, Palestine will be free!"

Moving my mind to another era of history, I put myself in another man's shoes, I imagined living in British Palestine in the 1930s, fighting a guerrilla war against the oppressive British mandatory government, and at the same time joining the allies, including the hated Britain, to fight Hitler's Germany. The Third Reich, meanwhile, was active in Palestine despite British presence, and working closely with the Arab High Committee to incite anti-Jewish riots. like the Kristalnacht of 1933. What should have been natural intersectional alliance between historical related Jewish and Arab nations against Turkish, British, French, and German outsiders, instead became a bitter and deadly rivalry, after an European imperial power pitted the brothers against one another, in order to divide and conquer them both. The resistance to this many headed imperial beast, is the decolonial struggle of the national liberation movement of the Jewish people, also known as zionism.

This is the liberation movement, in other words, that we in the plaza were gathered to oppose. Why is Jewish liberation is the enemy. And who are we, the petty bourgeois, WASP children of privelege, representing, again, if not the imperial beast itself?
How reduction of Jewish sovereignty to 0% from its current and historic high of 0.01% serve the interest of civil justice, or black, or indigenous, or arab liberation?

None of was mentioned during the rally, of course. No Palestinian history whatsoever was presented either. It was merely assumed and accepted as a matter of fact that Israel was the imperial power, simply because of US allied with it againt the Arab League, which was armed and financed by the USSR. The US, like all Europe, imposed an arms blockade on the entire region in 1948, which disproportionately hurt Israel, given that the Arab Legion was trained and supplied by the British, and led by a British officer in the Arab war of agression that failed and resulted in the Palestinian Nakba and the independence of Israel. This Israel-US alliance, by the way, only began to form after Israel defeated Egypt and Syria and their allies in the 1967 six-day war.

Organizers continued to agitate the crowd. And getting everyone to stand and put their fists in the air again, my worst fears were confirmed.

"Death to Israel!" yelled the organizers up front. Agitators in crowd repeated the mantra. The crowd gradually joined in, and soon it became a chant, and the mob joined them in indulging and cultivating rage, finding joy in the rush of empowerment that this ritual brings, and solidarity in the experience of a common purpose and a united front.

Among hundreds of young white people standing with their fist in the air, explictly rejecting the two-state solution in order to conduct an all out war aimed at the "death of Israel".

Distressed and bitter, I kneeled in their midst. I wouldn't be a part of this. It is clear from these chants that the negotiations are not being done in good faith by the palestinians and by their progressive allies: their explicit goal is to destroy the Jewish state, and possibly also to bring death to Israelis. To blame Israel for the failure is adding dishonesty and slander to the lack of good faith. And its explicitly violent as well. How could we progressives fall for this?

Of all the chants the we in this demographic had repeated for hours on end, during the prior month of protesting (and occasional rioting), none had called for anyones death. Dismantling white supremacy, yes. Abolishing police, yes. There had been graffitti to kill cops, which I always marked over in my spray-paint runs, but no chants to kill cops, hated as they are. Why are we now calling for the "death" of tiny little nation in the near east, that is surrounded by enemies, and the homeland of a historically oppressed people?

There is a claim that the instinct for self-defense when surrounded by hostile people is somehow "right-wing". But when an ethnic minority is delegitimized, bullied, blamed for the problems of the whole world, and then threatened with "death" by militants who are ostensibly left-wing, the choice to take up arms and defend themselves is a response that is neither leftist nor rightist, but merely human. To call it "right-wing", after construing that as the source of all evil, is a form of racism, in that it denies the basic human instinct for survival. And it is a double standard, given the support the left shown for armed black militants. We DSA people need to confront the systemic racism in our organization and in the political left generally.

there were probably a few brainwashed (or terrified) jews, afraid to mark themselves as different from the crowd.

As I was kneeling among those standing and chanting for the death of Israel with their fists in the air, and felt the eyes of opprobrium form all around boring into my scalp.

Never in my life have I felt so alone.

"Zionist sympathizer," I felt them say, "Stop the tone policing, lib. How dare you tell us what to do?" I felt like I was now marked as the very embodiment of evil. The rest of the July I tried to start conversations about liberation and anti-racism, but never wore all-black to join the "Bloc", and my non-participation was conspicuous. The militants avoided me. "That guy is suspect, don't get too close to him. He's a zionist; probably working with the cops," were words I felt more than heard.

After what seemed like minutes, the chanting subsided, and more speakers told the stories of their lives and rage.

One of the MCs or organizers went through a ten point "breaking the myth" that anti-zionism is anti-semitism. I won't bore you with the details; the refutations were sophistical and unsound, and the original point ought to be considered. Given that they are calling for the "Death of Israel"I am more convinced than ever that this anti-zionist BDS movement is, in fact, Jew hate. Why not simply build an Arab palestinian state at peace with its neighbor? Well, you might say, "they stole the land, why should we allow that and not fight them?". But unlike the English and Spanish settler colonialists, who stole the land in the Americas and Australia from the indigenous peoples there, Jews bought all the land they settled on prior to 1948. Perhaps for this reason, the issue wasn't discusssed; At no point in the gathering was there discussion of Palestinian history, culture, national identity, or vision for political future, nor any reference to the surrounding Arab states. There was no explicit mention of religion at all, or reference to G*d, or Allah. The focus of the gathering was entirely and exclusively on Israel and Zionism, without any historical context, defined only in the negative as the source of all suffering that arab Palestinians have suffered from imperial colonialism.
  Zionism is also a convenient scapegoat for progressive militants who hate religion in general and lack the the historical awareness to bring a critique of Christian dominionism in US history, which is itself rooted in anti-zionist Jew hate, supercession, and replacement. Israel is also a much easier target to attack; it is a small, and relatively weak country and easier to destroy than the United States, and makes an easy test case for those who wish to abolish national borders and capitalism. That is what is going on, and it is Jew hate to fixate on the one and only Jewish state in the world. Why not destroy Canada or Australia? Those are far more "imperialistic".

I find the whole basis for the claim of palestinian victimhood here to be intellectually dishonest, since they are explictly rejecting the two-state solution and calling, not only for war against Israel, but a total war that ends in the "death of Israel". It seems to me that if you are the aggressor in a racist and genocidal war, and you then lose that war, you will probably lose some territory. This is what happens in war. Germany lost Alsace to France and Pomerania to Poland, after losing a war of aggression, and it won't get those territories back.

I thought about leaving, but I wasn't ready to out myself as a counter-protestor, nor was I willing to yield the public square. Yelling can't silence this, only truth can. I calmed myself and tried deliberate non-participation and non-retreat. I was staging a sit-in

  • an anarchic, spontaneously organized protest against violent rioting. The truth is mightier than all things. If mob rule and passive submission to violent demagogues who scapegoat minorities with dishonest rhetoric is what democratic socialism brings us to, I don't intend to support or be ruled by that any more than I do Tromp's version of it on the right wing. In that moment, all of a sudden, I became a practical anarchist, albeit a non-destructive one. It was almost like being born again, I suppose. I've had almost nothing to do with DSA since that point, although I'm still paying dues. As I contemplated these things, matters were escalating around me.

A leader got on the mike put his fist in the air, and chanted.\ "Death to America!" Agitators in the crowd responded in rythym, and, keeping time, the mob joined in, fists in the air. The crowd was on its feet. I remained kneeling on the grass, trying to make myself as small as possible.

I was chilled to my core. I wanted to leave, but was unable to. I felt the eyes of hatred boring into me from all around. Who was I to resist? What was wrong me? What horrible moral defect could induce me to support such evil, by my non-compliance? "white man. You think your're better than us, zionist? Your privelege is showing. how dare you?" In my mind's ear I could feel the contempt drilling into me into confessional solidarity. I was tempted to stand.

The chant continued, louder. "Death to America". I've heard about terrorism before, but I'd never felt it before. In retrospect, I doubt that my peers were thinking these things about me. I suspect that some of them were as terrified as I was, and simplied complied in order to save their reputations if not their lives. The grimaces were probably their own struggles with the same thing I was experiencing in that moment. Perhaps sadness as their own complicity withis display of violent hatred. In support of this theory, I never heard either of these chants repeated again, although I was out four to six nights a week for the rest of the July and beyond.

Not just that such things would be said, but that so many young almost all white Americans could be so easily led to say such a thing. It wasn't communist revolution being sought; there was no class consciousness here, and although it sought the overthrow of the state, it clearly wasn't anarchic, nor was it theocratic in any sense, since the divine was completely ignored. I had only conceived of fascism in it mature phase, as Mussolini or Franco, but I had never before considered that it began as a mass movement of the proletariat and petty-bourgeouis, very much like communism in that respect. The nazis also had to defund the police, so that they could successfully smash Jewish owned business, they rioted with impunity until they were able to seize power. I've concluded that it was fascism in its germinal phase that I was witnessing, masquerading as anti-fascism, and it was pollinated by a mature variety from another land. It is an ideology that worships power and relies on scapegoating vulnerable minorities. If you weren't aware, the Arab High Committee of British Palestine allied with the Nazis during WWII.

I'm not sure if the flag burning occured before or after these chants, but it wasn't the main event. I would be interested in reviewing the MSM coverage of this event, I suspect its the only newsworthy item they managed to understand and report, given their deplorable ignorance and even obfuscation of the underlying issues.

Not until recently did I do some research, and discover that the Day of Rage was a coordinated global protest by Samidoun, palestinian prisoner exchange. They claim to be grassroots and unfunded, but from the evidence on the ground alone, that is clearly not the case - they were the best organized event of the sixty to a hundred that I attended this summer in Portland. Their call to action is translated into seven languages, took place in major cities on every continent, in multiple coordinated stages form July 1st to July 4th. They know how to trigger an uprising, an intifada, and that is exactly what happened in Portland. Here's what the NGO monitor has to say about this 'grassroots, unfunded group': "The Coordinator of Samidoun, Khaled Barakat, is on the central committee of the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, a terrorist organization designated by the US State Department. This and many other ties are acknowledged by the PFLP itself."

The PFLP is designated as a terrorist group by the European Union, as well as by the US State Department.

As you can see from their own website and propaganda, the call to action by this "grassroots, unfunded" group was translated into seven languages, and coordinated protests took place in major cities on every continent, in stages from July 1st to July 4th.

https://samidoun.net/2020/06/day-of-rage-join-the-actions-around-the-world-to-say-no-to-annexation-no-to-zionism-1-july-and-onwards

What is the Humanitarian response?

Not knowing any of what I've only recently learned about Samidoun and BDS, I spent the rest of the summer and the fall in the plaza opposing both the latently fascist worship of police and military as "heroes", and also anarcho-communist worship of the raw power of the raised fist and endlessly repeated slogan. It is more dangerous to leave and ignore this, than to stand one's ground and resist.

Which is also how I feel about the latent fascism both in our police as well as in the anarcho-communist militant antifa black bloc, and the other blocs, and their sympathizers. We scored a major victory against police lawlessness with the passage of Portland's ballot measure 26–217, which is the strongest police accountability in the nation. But there are other oppressive movements as well, such as political islamism and christian dominionism. And both of these relgio-political movements have jew-hate and anti-zionism at their core.

There is also and neo-liberal passive accomodationism. Civic leaders, parents, and teacher should take counter-measures, starting with political and historical education. There is a culpable ignorance on almost ever level of society. Thats why I helped organize the @IronFrontPNW Never Again. Listen.

We cannot afford to continue yielding the public square to this, as we have done all summer long. On the week following the Israel-UAE normalization agreement, the "Abraham Accords", a synagogue in SW mysteriously caught, and the media downplays it like its a coincidence, even though eggs were also thrown at a neighboring synagogue. Later that week, the same synagogue was burned again, this completely destroyed. Even though arson is now presumed, none of the media are admitting that it could be an anti-semitic attack, or that it might have had something to do with rest of the rioting this summer or with the violent anti-zionist rhetoric from the leftist community.

Thankfully no lives were lost, but the arson is a direct result of our unwillingness to take a stand against Jew-hate. Despite finding the time to riot for the cause of black lives, almost every night, none of the other radical leftist groups found the time to come and demonstrate the "Jewish Lives Matter", or that destroying a synagogue is not ok, even if you disagree with Israel's policies.

To my knowledge, no Portland political candidate or mainstream group denounced this except Commissioner Jo Ann Hardesty on Facebook. The abolitionists, who have been the ones driving the headlines, hate what she stands for, because she is a reformist. On the other side, white nationalists groups in the typical paranoid style, blame globalists, george soros, and the illegal zionist entity, whom they believe is paradoxically funding these same antifa/blm/bds protests and paying them to riot. Even if one of their spectrum committed the arson - which is plausible as well - the radical left is complicit by its incitement and by its silence. As we have been saying in the plaza all summer, "White silence is violence." To be silent at a time like this, when protests occur almost every night against anti-black racism? Not one protest against the jew hatred manifested by synagogue burnings? And "Back-the-blue" protestors don't miss an opportunity to denounce Antifa, and they show up every week to defend the police as if they need defending against Antifa, but can't be bothered to denounce BDS/BLM/Antifa on this? Jew-hate is the lowest common denominator that brings the radical left and the alt-right together in silent complicity. The news media failure to investigate or report is silent complicity.

To all radicals, I ask you to embrace the Jewish national liberation movement called zionism as your natural intersectional ally in the struggle against imperialism, colonialism, and Christian dominionism. Surely you can criticize Israel's policies, but I ask you to dismiss the BDS movements rejection of Israel itself, and denounce this event in particular. It is possible to criticize the state of Israel's policies without denying its right to exist. Denying a peoples national aspirations is a hatred of that people. To the extent that this is going on, then yes, your anti-zionism is jew-hatred; they events of the summer have demonstrated that.

Palestine is a Colonialist construct of the Roman Empire and its Western European heirs.

The Jewish settlers in British Palestine fought a political and guerrilla insurgency against the British, as if there was no Nazi Germany. And it simultaneously allied with the British to fight Germany, as if there was no "White Paper".

The word is a Greek word that was, and still is, a foreign, european import, and it imposed on the land of Israel (as it was called by its inhabitants) by the Roman empire after it occupied, colonized, and conquered Judea. The truth must be told. Jewish people are indigenous to the land, and Israel is an indigenous liberation movement. History Matters.

Sincerely.

((Adi)) Jared Essig

ואתה, ה"ה מגן בעדי כבודי, ומרים ראשי

on behalf of @IronFrontPNW, affiliates, and allied groups Join us in the radical, intersectional liberation struggle against fascism in all its forms

short videos

petitions