by Jared Essig © September 06 2021, last modified.
This article describes the events preceding my crime of assaulting my college professor on 30 Oct 2000, and my insights into the psychic conditions that led me to it.
For the etiology of the Intellectual Illness Entrained by Miseducation.
For the crime itself against professor Fred Sontag Z"L, see: Guilty of Assault Without Malice Aforethought
For the subsequent fifteen years of misdiagnoses and psychiatric mistreatment, see: Injustice, Misdiagnosis, and Mistreatment
For my alternative theory and practice of intellectual, moral, and mental health, see: Lunatic Mental Health
This is a draft v.4
Crimes of Philosophy
.. perhaps more accurately this could be called the crimes of a lack of philosophy, and of a hypocritical masquerade.
A Senior at Pomona College, Fall '00
.. majoring in "Philosophy" and minoring in Mathematics and Pre-Med, living in Clark V dorm, president of my dorm, and a member of student government leading the films committee, and member of a "greek fraternity".
Indulgent Excess and Ritual Degradation
The "social life" of the college is indulgent and absurd, both that sponsored by the dean's office of student life, and that which occurs in the dorms. I attribute this to a lack of value placed on the applied arts or the human factors of labor, a typical error of the upper classes. I analyze it elsewhere.
So I joined a hipster "fraternity." In prior years, I've had two prior "manic episodes" after fraternity hazing with its ritual degradations through drunkenness, misogyny, and subtle homoerotic abuse of pledges, and I was forced to see a psychologist. But the episodes were misattributed to "substance abuse" or to my biochemical potential for mania, rather than the moral errors of the fraternity, for example, its basic violation of the principle Thou shalt not commit adultery1, and to my shtus in joining it (my willingness to be seduced and misled). This was causing me seasonal anxiety around the rush and initiation week, because I did not want to either quit the frat or initiate pledges into it, and I wasn't aware my own feelings much less able to analyze them. This root cause of mania was never addressed in the years of "therapy" I would later be forced into, in 2000-2014
Only recently have I begun to mentally heal from this, which can only happen through repentance, confession, and acknowledging the true and good. Pledge: Health, Reason, and Virtue. Renounce: drunkenness, hazing, and misogyny
To Expiate the Absurdity of Our Condition
{{expand section}} c.f. Camus, Sartre, et al.
Vicarious Violence Against the Weak and Helpless
My sophomore year, I'd accidentally impregnated my girlfriend. Without any couples counseling, she'd been pressured into an abortion by the administration and student health clinic. After she informed me of her "choice", I assisted her in obtaining one. Whether this violates the prohibition "Thou shalt not murder"2 is at least debatable, yet not even a discussion was ever had about the ethics of it, either at college, or for the following 10 years of "treatment". If not murder, it was at least negligent manslaughter, or else a manifestation part of a morbid social complex, in my retrospective opinion, and both I and the college were complicit. There was no meeting with dean of students, or of women, or of men, no offer of support for her as a student mother or us as parents, no discussion of giving the baby up for adoption, and general contempt within the academic philosophy and ethics for "revealed ethics" such as the principle "be fruitful and multiply, fill the earth and cultivate it"3 or any of the others quoted here. Even though the principles can be inductively derived from natural philosophy, without the benefit of "revelation", they were never even considered as a possibility worthy of being refuted in my ethics class, they were simply ignored. She was a feminist, but told me later that she wished she'd been given a choice, since I hadn't proposed marriage. I had no role models for marriage; despite the obsessive fornication (encouraged and promoted by the dean and office of student life), there were no married students among the upperclassmen. (If students got married or had children, they might drop out, and damage the college's statistics and ranking.) I wasn't ready to take vows, and I hadn't heard of common law marriage, nor did I know anything about law or contracts, and neither did the deans or professors, apparently. In her words, she felt that she "had no choice" but to get an abortion, and after that semester, she dropped out of college. I dealt with my confused feelings through over stimulation - seeking promiscuous sexual and romantic experiences, transcendental romantic idealism, mysticism, and gnostic self-realization promoted by many peers and faculty. These traumatic and overstimulated experiences, socio-political situations, belief patterns, choices, are (obviously) causes of the mania, yet they were never addressed in the years of "therapy" I would later be forced into, in 2000-2014, and consistently downplayed by my therapists and social workers when I discussed them as causes of my mania and distress. The reason they deny and minimize the possbility of moral error or post-traumatic stress as a causative factor in the mental illness, is that the ideological system they inherit and uphold is complicit in the moral errors that cause the trauma. It is systemic oppression of the young, aimed at upholding the decadent and self-indulgent stupidity of the elders. I am not here debating or even questioning the ethics of abortion, I am demanding the right to choice. The right to life is the most basic right of all. Neither she, nor I, nor our baby, were given that right as a family. I myself am complicit in this denial of the right to both choice and right to life, by not taking responsibility for my sexual acts and leaving her in profound insecurity, and for choosing to believe the lie that I could have as much as I want without results or consequences. I wish that I'd sought out Prof.Sontag at this point in my life, because he is one of the few faculty that probably would have helped us. It turns out that minority communities around the world are well aware that women are often pressured into abortions with little or no real choice offered.
Intifada and Premonitions of Another World War, 28 Sept '00
Between Israel, Islam, and "the West", after Palestinians launch the Al-Aqsa Intifada. The uprising began after a group of Israeli politicians visited the temple mount, where Jews are currently forbidden to pray by the Islamic guardians and by international consensus of "responsible adults." Discussing the subject, a friend says "the real problem in the middle east is that Israel has no right to exist," and I find myself agreeing with him.
Priveleged White Liberal Supremacy and Basic Ignorance
My friend and I could have asked ourselves the question, "What right does America have to exist? What right did Britain have to colonize the Americas, or America to colonize and to claim California? What right did Rome have to colonize Judaea? What right did it have to eventually beseige and burn Jerusalem and the temple in 70C.E., renaming the region Palestine? What right do we have to legitimate and perpetuate this legacy, through tendentious denial and distortion of the facts? We could have investigated the ideological grounds for "Manifest Destiny" and American Exceptionalism, and our own WASP privelege. We could have discovered the roots of the protestant christian dominionismon which Pomona College was founded, in roman catholic European imperialism: the claim of the Nicean council that christians have abrogated the Torah law, have claimed all the priveleges and none of the responsibilities of that law, and have superseded Jews as "kingdom of priests", and have replaced all the biblical sacraments with cracker and grape juice on sunday morning, with the church as the "spiritual Israel". But we didn't do that analysis, and perhaps we avoided the subject (as did our professors), because it would have led us to the conclusion that our own WASP privelege was built on a set of hermeneutic perversions of both the new testament and the original one, supporting a brazen fraud and "noble lie", a basic violation of the command, "Thou shalt not covet ... anything that belongs to your neighbor."4 What we covet is not so much their land, but most of all, their role as the "light to the nations". We wish to promote ourselves in that position instead: institutions like Pomona exist on that premise. And for that reason, many of us western liberals would prefer that the Arabs, even our Islamist enemies, held the land rather than the Jews. But what kind of "light" are we to the nations?
Instead of doing this analysis and making this critique, we perversely decided to ignore the history, ignore the textual evidence, and project the guilt for our own western european and anglo-american sins of imperialism and colonialism onto the only Jewish state in the world, which is itself a victim of that imperialism, and like America and most other Asian and African post-colonial states, had to fight a war of independence against Britain. They'd previously struggled for independence against the Ottoman empire, and afterward had to defend against a war of agression launched by Nasser in his attempt at a pan-Arab caliphate/empire. But denying and misrepresenting these facts in order to legitimate and perpetuate violence aimed at destroying the Israeli nation-state, my friend and I were engaging in the same stupid and ignorant anti-Jewish scapegoating that has been going on in Europe for 2,000+ years.
Trained in Systemic Jew-Hatred
(At this point in my life, never been to a synagogue, never learned of a single event in Jewish history after the book of Acts, not even the holocaust since that was taught to me as an attack on humanity in general in 9th grade and ignored thereafter, and never even met a "Jew" in my life, since and all my "jewish" friends are totally assimilated and I've learned nothing about their beliefs or culture, never experienced a Jewish sabbath or biblical) holiday, never heard a Jewish interpretation of the hebrew bible. However, as a hermeneutic figure and as a straw man of polemics, "the Jew" figures large in my imagination and in many theories about what was and is wrong with the world. The attribution is commonly used in debate to smear of one's opponent: "like a Pharisee ..", "like the Jew's of old ..". From my youth to the present, everyone around me in secular and religous circles has held a reflexively anti-Israel political ideology as well as an anti-Jewish philosophy, christian zionists are held to be delusional idiots and fringe extremists. My philosophy major has totally ignored biblical, scholastic, and Jewish philosophy, as if it simply doesn't exist, except as an ignorant superstitution that we've progressed beyond. I've been taught philosophies that expect them to convert and assimilate, or else disappear, and exit the stage of history to make way for "progress", and I had always assumed that this would happen or already had. The academic world of my high school and college was one in which and there were no more Jewish intellectuals in the schools or universities, their books had been consigned to the dustbin of history, and the Nazi dream had succeeded - "the era of rampant Jewish intellectualism was at an end.")
My friend and I say that "Israel has no right to exist", and my philosophy professors treat the Jewish people as if they never did exist or have nothing worthy to report in the fields of ethics, metaphysics, or politics. They propagate the same philosophies that led to world war and genocide of the Jewish people, as if these events either did not occur, or are not worthy of philosophic investigation or ethical judgement. We were all in violation of the prohibition: "You shall not bear false witness against the life of your neighbor" 5
(Given that I was not testifying in a court of law, my "false witness" didn't constitute the crime of perjury, but it was at least philosophic and ethical malpractice, analogous to that of my professors. I began the self-examination and moral reasoning for the first time starting in 2014, after I escaped the mental health system, and had my second "awakening of conscience" from the dogmatic slumber of progressive modernism. During the period of my "treatment" 2000-2014, I was forced to accept the proposition that I was physiologically inferior, and that the awakening of my conscience was a "psychosis" and a "delusion", and that I must obey the psychiatrist and the administrators.
In many ways, my "existential thought experiment" ruined my life and my career. However, it did succeed in helping me learn Plato's republic, which I could never have learned at Pomona. In order to understand this treatise, the foundation of Western political science, its necessary to see it from the perspective those people who are "bronze and iron".6
The evil of graeco-roman imperialism in which we are trained is deeper than mere "white supremacy", although that is a real part of it. It has a diversity program and individuals of ethnic minority can act it out once they are indoctrinated into its errors and given priveleges according. Jews are hated (like indigenous peoples), not because of their "race" or their language, but because they represent the possibility of an alternate political reality. Academia is a neo-platonic cult that trains liberal elites in a program of authoritarian (occasionally fascistic) mind control through both culpable ignorance and deliberate deception. Despite the attempts to spiritually and intellectually assassinate me, I am one of the few whose intellect survived intact through the indoctrination and institutionalization.
But my teachers, pastors, therapists, doctors, and lawyers are in culpable ignorance and tendentious denial. _
The Hollow Foundations of Progressive Modernity
For the first time in my life, I was forced to confront the fact of Jewish political identity and presence in history. This destabilized me intellectually and mentally, because the enlightenment ideologies which I've spent the last four years expect them to disappear. I was still very committed and attached to these enlightenment "ideals", but I lacked the historical awareness or critical thinking skills necessary to analyze them successfully (as I'm doing after now in 2021), or to evaluate my own experiences in light of current events.
The Unbearable Ennui of Aimless Hedonism
Pomona's "Harwood Halloween" happens that year on Saturday night, a giant extravaganza of booze, pop music, lewdness, which like most of the other "social life" on campus is mostly empty and devoid of meaning or purpose. I'm on student government and helped organize the party, so I stay sober. I become suspicious that the social life we are building at Pomona is ethically bad and also a delusional escape from reality, and begin to emotianally detach from it.
In retrospect, the entire college sponsored "campus life" establishment is based on regressive taxation and wealth transfer from underclassmen to seniors, in order to maintain a system of feudal privelege for the upper classmen, control of alcohol and party scene, and as such violates the command "Thou shalt not steal". I analyze this elsewhere. The frat I'm in is basically an anarcho-communist cell fighting a battle designed to lose while perpetuating its own micro-economy of despair, hedonic excess, and mutual aid. Like many of them, it is misogynistic, homoerotic, devoted to drunkenness and to the type of promiscuity that verges on polyamorous wife-"sharing", to lawless rebellion. It priveleges the upperclassmen at the expense of the under classes, but I lack the courage to quit, or the analytic skills to critique it (as do, apparently, the rest of the faculty). It seems that it is (we were) merely a reflection of and an auto-immune response to the diseases of the mainstream social life and amorality of the intellectual culture. Both sides are in violation of the commandment "Thou shalt not commit adultery", as am I by virtue of my participation in both - since promiscuity, polyamory and abortion are encouraged, whereas marriage and children are discouraged. (Only recently in 2020 have I renounced it. See: Pledge: Health, Reason, and Virtue. Renounce: drunkenness, hazing, and misogyny )
After the halloween party, I go back to my room and stay up all night reading books on the intellectual history of western civilization, which elevates my mania.
The False Prophet and the Antichrist?
29 Oct 2000 These questions .. strike me, after having stayed up most of the previous night, and all day Sunday, reading and writing. I began to suspect that like Nietzsche, I am an antichrist. (I'd studied Nietzsche for my "Continental Thought" and "History of Ethics" classes, and been seduced by his vision of gnostic self-realization through will-to-power, which was promoted by Prof. Erickson, without any critical examination of how his supremacy theories, paganism, imperialism, and "blond beast of prey", "beyond good and evil" anti-morality contributed to the world wars, or how his anti-Jewish "geneaology of morality" contributed the the holocaust. (Yeah I know, he wasn't an anti-semite like his sister, he was just a hater of Judaism). Heralding "a new Platonic age", Erickson takes us from the early Nietzsche, to Hesse's Demian, to Hiedegger, from riffs on the warrior ethos and the hero's journey in popular novels, movies, psychology and psychoanalysis, and culture, without any discussion of french philosophy, jewish history or philosophy, or the holocaust, or of the UN declaration on human rights, or of the post-war situation. This charismatic professor basically trained us in all the intellectual precursors of nazi ideology, and made it seem very seductive and popular, without any moral accountability or even acknowledgement of its aftermath - a soft form of not merely holocaust denial, but denial of reality. The denial continued by Prof.Bok in my History of Ethics class, whose only rejoinder to my question was that the Nazi's misunderstood Nietzsche on some points, ignoring how much of it they understood only too well. The later Nietzsche is not insane, as the professors insist - it his early work they love so much, which is insane as well immoral, imperialist war-mongering. His later work is supreme philosophic genuis and analytic clarity. He demonstrates the error of his earlier work, and predicts the both the rise and demise of Nazism through self-parody and coprophagia. I invite Bok and Erickson to sit with me in the mental hospital, and if they are too proud to eat their own shit like Nietzsche did, I will spoon feed them some of my own. Until then, I dedicate my assault on Prof.Sontag to them, and may their memories rot for giving me the philosophic encouragement for doing it. Despite the the immorality and insanity of my crime, it was at least existentially "authentic", and ethically justifiable on the systems they taught me. Ecce Homo.
During the decades of my "treatment", I was forced to accept the proposition that I was psychotic and delusional. However, it is my considered opinion that the rest of progressive white society is in denial, and that I was NOT in delusion, and that, yes, [We Are The Antichrist]()
In retrospect, this fear of becoming an "antichrist" was not irrational - it was an accurate, pre-analytic assessement of what we are groomed for at Pomona: to proudly carry on the tradition of colonialism and imperialism through institutions of neo-liberal globalization supremacy. WASP institutions like Pomona have assumed a role of "chosen people", in settling the Americas under the theory of America as "promised land", we've claimed to replace the Jewish people while abrogating their law and covenant, and use the misappropriation of prophecies given to the them in order to justify seizing lands from indigenous Americans. Our religion is art, literature, and aesthetics, and we simultaneously benefit from and ignore christianity, while scapegoating Israel in order to avoid any critical thinking about this. We try to expiate the guilt of our legacy of christian dominionism through ennui, fashionable despair and aburdity, but we do so while benefiting from that legacy and without critiquing it or correcting any of its basic assumptions. And in order to avoid moral accountability, we suppress the history by either by claiming its inevitability (Christianity, Hegel, Michelet, Nietzsche, Marxism, Progressivism, Fukuyama), or else by denying historic causality altogether and cutting it into discrete, unrelated, almost random events (Hume, Darwin, Foucault et al). And the progressive left uses Zionism similarly to how the religious right uses Judaism - as a straw man on which to project our theories of what is wrong with the world, so that we can use Judaism or Israel as a scapegoat without having to critically examine our own "noble lies" or give up our own priveleges. Lacking the skills to analyze this, all I could do is intuitively grasp is that Pomona College is totally absurd and possibly evil. )
As it dawns on me for the first time that my class of graduates of "elite liberal arts" colleges have a "manifest destiny" to lead the world, and rule the rest of humanity, I become somewhat manic. Later diagnosed as "grandiosity" totally rejecting and dismissing the critical thinking I'd begun about the grandiosity inherent in our imperialism, christian dominionism, progressive modernity, social darwinism and white supremacy. In retrospect, the "mental health" establishment is part of the same grandiose "noble lie" taught at Pomona, and my "delusional thinking" was merely an attempt to understand my place within systems of oppression that we benefit from and implicitly support, and whose existence we deny or obscure. It was a necessary phase of renunciation.
Rebellion of the Conscience: The Wicked Flee When No One Pursues
Specifically, I begin to fear that I and my classmates are being groomed for positions as high-class servants of the world government of the antichrist. Having never thought critically about this before, having never discussed it with a professor or classmate, I didn't know what to do. Since my professor in analytic philosophy J.Atlas has previously invited me to tutorials at his private house library, and since he skeptically dismisses most continental and "modern" philosophy, I get in my car and begin driving there shortly after nightfall, hoping to ask him some questions and analyze these existential difficulties.
I parked my car at the Ralph's on the corner of Foothill and Indian Hill Blvds, and made a phone call from the pay phone, but he didn't answer. As I returned to my car, I didn't see it in the lot, momentarily forgot where I'd parked it, and suddenly presumed it stolen, presumed that I was being hunted, panicked, and fled. I ran through a residential neighborhood, hiding in bushes every time a car passsed. I went through several backyards, climbing over fences, terrified of every sound.
"The wicked flee when no one pursues but the righteous are bold as a lion." says Solomon in proverb 28:1 . My paranoia was not caused by a biochemical imbalance, it was caused by the wickedness into which I'd been trained and initiated. My conscience had been suppressed and denied for too long, and it rebelled against me, I became terrified of retribution, and a started fleeing from shadows. Given that I and my peers among the white liberal elite were trying to rule the rest of humanity while denying moral obligation, the rebellion of my conscience followed a moral logic that is not at all "delusional", but rather is a punishment that is exactly what I deserved for my pride and prejudice. The only way to heal and recover is through catharsis: the purification that occurs when suffering is accepted as divine justice. (Ka Taharah? This is an interesting question for scholars of Hebrew and Greek etymology to consider, and I would like to know what the answer is.)
After about half an hour, the initial panic wore off and I was back on the mostly empty street, slowly accepting the fact that I could die at any moment in a drive by shooting. I decided to not go quietly into that good night, and instead register an act of protest or a cry for help before I died at the hands of the antichrist minions (or at the hands of the resistance, since the evidence suggested that I myself was an antichrist minion. I couldn't figure out who were the good guys, who were the bad guys, or which side I myself was on.)
Breaking The Glass Window, Renouncing My Status
I walked up to the living room windows of a randomly chosen residential house, and kicked out the window, shattering it, and started yelling "I am of the second coming of Christ" up and down the street. The owner of the house came out and asked me why I did it, and I that is what I told him.
It was wrong to break that guy's living room window, and I admitted it when I was interrogated. I pledge to pay the cost of the window with interest, if I can find him. That would also save the public the cost of jailing me for a few days or month for the vandalism. Despite repeatedly admitting to this crime, to the police and investigators and later to the hospital clinicians, I was never charged with it by prosecutors, and the clinicians never addressed the "mental health" concerns that it should have raised. Instead, they charged me with a separate crime which I did not commit - petty theft from a Stater Bros. grocery which occured around the same time at a different location.
Jerusalem Syndrome as a Stage of Recovery
In short, I had the benign early symptoms of Jerusalem Syndrome. This begins not as religious delusion, but as a stage of recovery from religious delusions and cognitive disorders of supercesssionism found in christianity, islam, and progressivism. I did not believe myself to be the Christ, per se, merely aligned with the Human Christ, the Jewish Christ as constitutional monarch of Israel. In so doing, I was rejecting as "antichristian" the humanistic false messianism inherent in the progressivism of Pomona College. Instead I aligned with its opposite - a supernatural, superhuman return of Jesus as the Son of Man to the city of Jerusalem to sit on the throne of his father David judge between the nations. In the hospital, I was conditioned to see this as delusional, but I now reject that diagnosis. It may be wishful thinking to expect Jesus to return a second time on the clouds of heaven, but its not any more implausible than the central thesis of mainstream christianity, that he rose from the dead and is now seated at the right hand of God.
From the Neo-Platonic Cult of Academia
In my opinion, Academia is a neo-platonic cult that exploits rich and ambitious young people. Its a quasi-religion. Like Roman citizenship, its a pyramid scheme. It teaches them to sublty exploit others through ideology. I recommend that young people instead learn a trade, go to community college if necessary, and get married. Study Aristotle on evenings and the weekends at a public library or in a synagogue study hall with the disciples of Maimonides, because you are unlikely to find sound scholarship in private academies. If you choose the latter, pick a state college or public university - because non-students and parents can audit the professors, and thus they are more likely be intellectually honest. They can't hide behind private property; they are on public land and are forced to take all comers. Claremont McKenna has a "Lyceum". I imagine that scholarly discourse occurs there.
If I stand on a Honnold library lawn or in the Cruikshank-Pearson Quadrangle and publicly profess philosophy at Pomona or Claremont, as I did after my class reunion of 2016, they could have me arrested for trespass. (This did in fact occur. I was arrested at my own alma mater for showing up in a state of conspicuous poverty, and daring to profess post-apocalyptic and Aristotelian philosophy. Whereas at public universities, the 1st ammendment of the US constitution protects academic freedom.)
Arrested and Jailed for Public Intoxication
(https://unicourt.com/case/urc-FJCRSHJPIAYUUFUFMUZGHB3KMJKBC1046)
I made my way to a different strip mall on Foothill Blvd, several blocks west of the one I'd parked at. Without entering the store, I stood outside of a Stater Bros. grocery store, announcing the apocalypse and warning pedestrians of the imminent collapse of civilization.
A police car pulled up and officers hog tied me on the ground. When questioned, I claimed to have invented a novel psychedelic drug and gone under its influence. (this was my poetic way of describing the state of psychotic trance that I was in, also I was hoping that they would arrest me.) I was arrested for public intoxication, and later charged with a petty theft which I didn't commit and knew nothing about. I was happy to be arrested, and wanted to go to jail, because I felt that I would be in a more or less secure environment where I could gather my thoughts and make phone calls.
Despite admitting to breaking the window, the prosecutors didn't charge me with it, instead insisted on charging me with a separate crime "petty theft" from a grocery store, which I DID NOT commit, and my own lawyer attempted to pressure me into changing my "innocent/not guilty" plea into "NGI".
Continued here: Professor Fred Sontag Z"L
References
Nirenberg, David (2014). Anti-Judaism: The Western Tradition. W. W. Norton & Company. ISBN 0-393-34791-5.
Adler, Mortimer (1985). Ten Philosophical Mistakes: Basic Errors In Modern Thought - How they came about, their consequences, and how to avoid them. Macmillan. ISBN 0-02-500330-5.
- Solomon, Robert (1976). The Passions. Hackett Publishing. ISBN 0872202267.
Notes
-
Plato's Republic, Book __ describes a program of "eugenic" social and racial engineering by means of a "noble lie" taught by the ruling class of "guardians" in order maintain their own supremacy by means of deceiving the lower classes. The deception consists in creating "racial" categories in order to convince the lower classes of their genetic inferiority. ↩