by Jared Essig © February 07 2022, last modified.
This article is about my crime of assaulting my college professor, the night of 30 Oct 2000
_For the preceding events and a theory on the causes, see: The Crimes of Philosophy_
For court docket and transcripts, contact Pomona Superior Court, Re: Case No. KA050346. LA County Court Records
For journalist accounts, see below: 2000-2003 Journalist Accounts
_For the subsequent fifteen years of misdiagnoses and psychiatric mistreatment, see: Misdiagnoses and Mistreatment_
For my alternative theory and practice of intellectual, moral, and mental health, see: Lunatic Mental Health
A Plan to Withdraw from Pomona and Return to Oregon
was made in a phone teleconference between myself, my parents in Oregon, and Prof. Sontag, while I was still in jail on the charge of public intoxication. This seemed better to us than admission to a psychiatric facility, and I'm very grateful to Prof. Sontag for facilitating this. (and I still am grateful, because it was the right decision). A mental health worker interviewed me in jail, and determined that I didn't meet the criteria for involuntary admission to a psychiatric hospital, because I was "not a danger to self or others". I also think this was the correct decision, as my dangerousness stemmed almost entirely from what was about to happen next.
The Jailer Gives Me a Knife
And a baseball cap at the property counter as I was discharged, neither of which I'd ever seen before, along with the wallet and stuff that had been my pockets when I was arrested. This made me very paranoid, and I incorporated this into my paranoia as a "sign" from the "guardians" that there was a clandestine civil war amongst them, and that I should protect myself from a possible assasinationn, and that they were preparing me to defend myself by giving me the knife. Prior to this, I wasn't a danger to anyone.
At Sontag's Office with Dean Quinley
After picking me up from jail, Prof. Sontag drove me to his office in Pearson Hall where we met with Dean Quinley, who approved the plan that I would take a leave of absence from college and travel to Oregon. Although I didn't meet the criteria for involuntary hospitalization, it was apparent that I was psychotic and they didn't want me at the college in that state. Prof. Sontag then drove me to my dorm to pack a bag. The plan was to drive to his place afterward, where I would sleep on his couch and he would take me to the airport in the morning catch a flight home. He was very compassionate and I admire him for this, and I held nothing against him personally, and had abolutely no intention of hurting him. (I did have grounds to be suspicious of the entire faculty of the college for teaching my peers and me ignorance and denial, but at that point in my life, I didn't have the critical thinking skills to analyze it, so it appeared as a generalized phobia of authorities and teachers. Having considered the matter in later adulthood, I consider him the least intellectually dishonest and least psychologically avoidant of all the professors in the department.) We got into the car and started driving to my dorm building, which was the four or five blocks away.
I Panic and Try to Flee The Car
.. suspicious of a van that seemed to be following us. Prof. Sontag pulled into the parking lot across from my dorm. I wasn't able to open the door of Prof. Sontag's Volvo station wagon, which made me panic. Much later I learned that his station wagon had a child safety feature on it, but I had never been in a car like that and didn't know how to interpret the experience of being locked inside. It was only at this point, and never before, that I began to fear that Prof. Sontag. might be colluding to have me abducted. From the passenger seat, I was surveying the area hyper-vigilantly, fearful that a van or ambulance of imperial government agents would kidnap me, subject me to medical and psychological experiments, and force me to work for them. (In a bitter irony, this proved to be a self-fulfilling premonition of the coercive treatment I would receive over the following ten years in the forensic mental health system, where I worked to provide employment for clinical staff. )
I Brandished The Knife, He Demanded That I Turn It Over
With my right hand, facing the street to my right. Prof. Sontag was on my left, and I did not menace him directly with the brandished knife, and he knew this.
He asked me to turn over the knife TWICE. The first time I said, "I can't do that." The second time he asked was with a heightened tone of authority, which triggered my phobia of authorities. I shook my head and said "No," in a heightened tone of determination.
He was acting as a "guardian" of the republic, on the principle learned from his teacher Plato, that it is a good and wise deed to seize a sword from a madman, by force if necessary. I cannot fault him for this. Since he had good reason to seize the knife, I can't claim that I acted in real self-defense, although that is honestly how the situation subjectively appeared to me in my paranoid state.
I Assaulted Prof. Sontag
When Prof. Sontag reached across my body and attempted to seize the knife from my right hand, I stabbed him once in his exposed neck area, intending to push him away. It was a reflex, not an intention. I did NOT intend or desire to kill him, and had no idea when I brandished the knife that I would be stabbing him with it. To keep him away, I jabbed tentatively at him a second time, but recoiled my hand as soon as it touched him, and medical records confirmed that this second wound did not pierce the skin. If I had wanted to kill him, I could have easily done so, but I DID NOT BEAR ANY MALICE TOWARD PROF. SONTAG, nor did I seek his death. He knew this, and unlike the prosecutors, he was a witness to the events. Thats why he visited me in jail, campaigned the college not expel me, and urged the prosecutors to reduce the charges, which they refused to do. He also told the court that I was "insane", clearly not in my right mind, and should be given treatment rather than punishment.
These events would transpire six months later, after my period of "incompetence to stand trial" ended and I accepted the plea bargain that he, my parents, and my "lawyer" forced on me to this effect. My lawyer would not allow me to stand trial for the crime, threatening to hold me in jail under "incompetence" statute until I accepted the plea bargain. Had I stood trial, I would have pled: Guilty of Assault Without Malice Aforethought, and I would have accepted the sentence of the court, probably to at least a few years of prison time. It would have been obvious during testimony and cross-examination that this was due to an Intellectual Illness Entrained by Miseducation.
This illness was also, incidentally, the experience of many of Socrates' other young students. At least, of those who did not succeed in colonizing and tyrannizing the other Greek city-states, as we are trained to do by Plato at the Academy.
Perhaps thats why I did not succeed in gaining a trial, and why the moral order continues to be denied by those in power.
Crimes of Philosophy
During the four years of my education, I had become increasingly demoralized and confused, as a result of viciousness practiced in the social life and denials of intelligent design in nature, of purpose to life, and of moral knowledge in humankind - this dogmatic agnosticism and ignorance pervaded the social sciences, humanities, natural sciences, and philosophy. Prof. Sontag was one of the few professors to speak against this, and to comment on social issues as a public intellectual. However, his ability to make a thorough critique so was compromised by alliance with neo-platonic churchiantiy and sports teams.
See also: Crimes of Philosophy
He Opens the Door For Me to Flee the Car
After I stabbed him, I dropped the knife on the floor of the car, and continued trying to open the door and exit, but was unable to. Prof. Sontag saw my unsuccessful efforts, and reached across my body to unlock the door, and open it for me. After he did this, I immediately got out of the car and fled.
Arrested and Charged
I was walking around campus, and I waved down a campus security officer and confessed to him, saying "I think I killed Dr. Sontag". He called the Claremont police, who took me into custody. My pessimistic assessment was wrong, thank God: he survived, had surgery that night, and recovered fairly quickly. I was charged with attempted murder. The proceedings are on public record at Pomona Superior Court, Case No. KA050346. LA County Court Records
I Tried to Plead GUILTY
to "brandishing a weapon" and "assault with a deadly weapon, without malice aforethought", although both are mitigated by the fact that I sincerely but paranoically believed that I was acting in self-defense.
I was "represented" by Atty. Stuart Holmes who negotiated a plea bargain with the DA for NGI on attempted murder, and then forced me against my will to accept the deal, by threatening to hold me in jail indefinetely as "incompetent to stand trial", until I submitted to it.
I wrote a letter to the Student Newspaper apologizing to the entire student body for my actions. Unfortunately at that point, I had dismissed the realizations that had come during the pyschosis, having been coercively re-indoctrinated in the ideology of all the doctors, parents, and teachers - which denies the moral knowledge, rejects attempts at critical thinking about white supremacy or christian dominionism, a reduced everything to a "biochemical imbalance", essentially scapegoating my physical nature for my conceptual and moral errors and for those of society and western civilization as a whole, instead of correcting them.
Prof. Sontag Visited Me In Jail
Multiple times, and I profusely apologized to him, and he publicly forgave me. He did not press the charges, which were picked up and pressed by the District Attorney. He renounced the charge of attempted murder, and stated publicly that I "was not in [my] right mind", and that I should be given psychological help instead of punishement.
The administration of Pomona tried to have me expelled from the College, apparently, but he advocated for me to finish my degree by correspondence, which I did.
As a christian pastor and neo-platonic philosopher, he appeared to be a leader of the WASP aristocracy at Pomona. But when he visited me in jail, I asked him the meaning of his name "Sontag". He tells me that his Russian-Jewish parents took the name which means "Sunday" to escape pogroms, before eventually emmigrating to the U.S, where they converted to Christianity in order to fit in.
Prof. Sontag Was Also a Victim of Systemic Jew-Hate In Academia
I now believe that he was a victim systemic anti-Jewish hatred in the American universities, just as his parents were victims of it in Russia. He converted, assimilated and became, to some degree, a spokesperson for and co-perpetrator of the same system that was oppressing him and his people. It is latent in academic philosophy and western democracy, because it is fundamental to christian dominionism, post-christian progressive modernity.
17 May 2001 Plead NO CONTEST and NGI
"No Contest" to the charge of "Attempted 2nd degree murder", but "Not guilty by reason of insanity". I finally submitted to my lawyer's demand to accept the plea bargain he had negotiated with the DA. I was committed to Patton State Hospital to serve a 13 year sentence. It was understood that under the NGI, I could be released early if I showed signs of recovery, or I could stay there the rest of my life.
For the remainder of my story, see the next article. Here are the parts where our stories continued to intersect:
- Misdiagnoses and Mistreatment Finished Senior Thesis in the Mental Hospital
- Misdiagnoses and Mistreatment Summer 2003, Prof Sontag Hires me as a Teacher's Aide
2000-2003 Journalist Accounts
College's Stunned by Professor's Stabbing
Student Arraigned in Stabbing of Teacher
Professor's Attacker is Found Mentally Ill
Professor's Philosophy of Life Unshaken By Stabbing
Making the Best of a Painful Experience
Frederick Sontag dies at 84
2021 Yahrzeit for Fred Sontag Z"L
RE: Yahrzeit for Fred Sontag Z"L Date: 7 June 2021
Hello classmates and friends,
Today is the 27th of the month Sivan. This would be the memorial day of Fred Sontag, professor of philosophy at Pomona college, who passed away on this date in the year 2009 / 5679, which fell on June 14th that year.
I recall him as a philosopher in the existentialist neo-platonic christian tradition, but it was not until after I left the college and he visited me in jail, that I learned the surprising "secret" - that his parents were Russian Jews who converted to Christianity and immigrated to America to escape persecution.
Since today is his memorial day (yahrzeit) in the hebrew calendar, I invite us to take some time, in honor of him and also of his parents. In Jewish tradition, the prayer "kaddish" is said on the memorial of a departed ancestor, teacher, or friend. The essence of the prayer is, "sanctified be thy name," a prayer that is also the essence of the Lord's prayer in Christianity, that begins with "our father".
Here is a musical rendition in kirtan call-and-response style. Kirtan Kaddish