by Jared Essig © November 27 2022, last modified.

Sontag is Justified and Courageous, Essig was Insane

To disarm a madman, is a good deed, and Sontag is both just and courageous in disarming the madman, and ultimately succesful in so doing. Despite advanced age, F.Sontag attempted to seize the weapon from a much younger man, at risk of great bodily injury to himself, and when Essig lashed out with the knife in response, Sontag suffered bodily injury, thereby put his own life in jeopardy to save the populace from any depredations that may otherwise have occured: therefore he is truly a guardian and not merely a professor. Terrified by the moral gravity of his action, by the sight of blood, by the fear of consequence, by furies unseen, or by the inevitability of political censure and divine retribution, the criminal dropped the weapon, fled the scene, and turned himself in to police and, believing incorrectly that he had slain Sontag, immediately confessed the crime of having stabbed him.

Essig is Culpable and Confessed

We stipulate that Jared Essig is culpable, for he brandished a weapon. But being that there was no malice aforethought, that he was paranoid at the time, and that he dropped the weapon, fled, and confessed, we can infer that he did not attempt murder. According to investigative psychologists, he perceived his actions as self-defense against the an immaterial psychic threat presented by a ubiquitous "Republic", and that this fear was temporarily and suddenly localized onto F.Sontag, who, as its guardian was attempting to seize the madman's perceived means of self-defense. And this deserves skeptical inquiry. Was the paranoia an extension of natural fear, or was it an unnatural chemical aberration? As a matter of jurisprudence, Essig was found not guilty, by reason of insanity. And here is the rub: Socrates is also culpable; it is well known, for he incites this, as a program of liberation from the corrupt Athenian priesthood, and the absurd stupidty of their epic poets. To the extent that Essig was a philosophy student, therefore, his insanity should not be held against him. More likely than not, he had no "chemical imbalance" but rather was performing a thought-experiment that got out of hand. Most likely, he was undertakng a skeptical inquiry into the foundations of moral knowledge, and he chose to employ the existential method rather than the academic one. If so, his thesis constitutes a refutation of the dogmatic agnosticism of the modern pyrrhonists who run the departments of philosophy and theology, insofar as they do actually believe in and rely upon the fact of moral knowledge and judgement, contrary to their professed agnostic pragmatism, insofar as their privelege rests on the acceptance of it by the helots and the vulgur democrats, whilst they "liberate" themselves to intemperate and immoral sensory indulgence. Reductio ad absurdum. None of them are just but Sontag. And there is no thesis more certain, or better defended, than that now offered by Essig: Athens is corrupt.

Athens Corrupts the Youth, and Socrates Drives Them Insane

Athens corrupts the youth, like Sparta and Crete also do. But Socrates Drives Them Insane He purports to do this as a program of liberation from the idols of the cave, which are now grandiose in the public square and worshipped in the temples. This is why Sontag sympathizes, and rightly so. However, Socrates is ignorant. The question is, why is he so persuasive?

Athens is a Hypocritical Drama and Tourist Trap; her Poets are Liars, her Priests are Absurd

Neither the priests nor the sophists can refute him, and this is compounded ad baculum. A sin against justice no less than against philosophy, and Athens is evidently foolish. In retrospect, Athens also corrupts the youth, for the Lyceum is a gymnastic, and cretan peaderasty has been made normative and almost mandatory. The training is exhausting, injurious, and homoerotic. (see Thesis II). The paranoia is natural phase of psychological recovery, in the case of young Essig, as it is in the case of all the other young disciples of Socrates. It is suddenly dawning on him, that he has been deceived and led astray from youth, for his own parents and teachers are all deluded. And they most probably are. Also, it appears from the forgiveness that Sontag extended, and his efforts on behalf of his attacker, that Sontag himself may have privately sympathized with this perception.

A similar process of forced assimilation to the Athenian absurd also happened to him when he was an undergrad. It happens to us all, but very few come of out the cave to regard the natural light, and those who leave tend to return to the illusion, for it is comforting. But eventually we all develop knawing suspicions and irrevokable realizations: either the priests are deluded, or the gods are vicious and perverse. Most likely, the poets are liars. At best, it is a hypocritical drama, at worst, a mesmerizing deception, on average, a tedious waste of time. The sophists at least are pragmatic, and subject to skeptical inquiry, and Socrates's ignorance is justifiable, because Athens is foolish.

The Academy is Spartan and Unnatural, Plato is Deceived

Therefore, the Academy is a place of refuge for those seeking liberation from the confusion that is Athens, and its idols of the theater, and many desire to matriculate. But F.Sontag's intellectual integrity and moral virtue is rarity among them, for he is a natural man, and the Republican Academy is deceptive and unnatural; and they deserve none of his merit. Plato is deceived, insofar as he idealizes Sontag alone advised young Essig on the manual arts, on marriage, and hebraic interpretation of the evangelists, and the others consider these questions unnecessary, for they are Spartan in their habits, for it's military power is attractive their innately greek hubris, and their ignorance is culpable denial. Sontag alone visited young Essig in hospital and jail, the other professors of so-called philosophy would not. Unlike Sontag, they are personally irresponsible, as they do also profess.

Since the legal defenders of young Essig declared him incompetent and forced the verdict of insanity and prevented him from making an apology in public court, we accuse them complicity with the Academy in seeking to avoid embarassment, for the Academy incited this behavior. Their educational design is conspicuous consumerism, conspicuous luxury, ritual violence, misogyny, class prejudice, moral agnosticism, and a rejection of trades and manual arts, and they need to assimilate people to this viciousness in order to train cadets for a militaristic oligarchy, which is their educational purpose. Sontag was a victim of this as well, and he was pressured to assimilate. Although intellectually and emotionally repressed, because pressured into denial, he sympathizes with young Essig's paranoia, because he knows that it is natural and valid response to Academic deception. Sontag's ignorance is righteous, like that of Socrates

Aristotle's Natural Philosophy is Perennial; Modernism is Tedious and Incoherent

The moderns are indistinct, lazy, incoherent, and tedious ramblers, to no discernable end except for language games, ornery agnosticism, materialist scientism, and a political theology that centers man (in this case, the white man), and serves the purpose imperial colonial policy cum neo-liberal globalization. It is mesmerizing, evil, and ultimately banal. And whether that policy be mercantile, or it be democratic and neo-liberal capitalist is for the economists to decide, and they so-called "philsophers" do not inquire, because they are too lazy to practice social science, and they have abdicated natural philosophy, and too proud to consider critical theory into their own origins. And its already defeated, but none would admit it. Insofar as "christian civilization" to which the College is a tribute claims to replace Jerusalem as "the light of the world", which has evidently supplanted Athens, and insofar as modernism claims to now replace christianity with scientism. Sontag is justified to ignore them They are ignorant because they are proud and unwilling to admit their incoherence, whereas Sontag is simple and to the point, and has more important lessons to teach his students, than to engage tedious discourses or tendentious debates with modern "professors" who refuse to do their homework. The College, like Athens, is ignorant because she is proud and foolish, therefore culpable. Socrates is merely a simpleton as regards the "knowledge" that they claim; because they know not whereof they speak, and he at least admits his simplicity. His humility and skeptical inquiry excuses him. He may be insane, but at least he is existentially authentic.

None of them save Sontag could spare the time to open up Aristotle's tractates and actually read them, because they despise the scholastics. They hold Aristotle guilty by association, although this is anachronistic, unjust, and possibly even intellectual dishonesty.

Plato is Redeemed by Remorse, Repentance, and Confession

And Plato, ah yes. This is hard for me to say, for he is kind, and beloved. But Plato is culpable, for he is Academic. And most of all, the Academy is culpable, for it is Spartan. And Sparta is a militarist oligarchy fit for nothing but war. The communism of wives and children is unnatural; commons sense opposes it for good reason; and Plato is blameworthy for idealizing its republic. Sparta and its "Academy" is hardly wise as our "Athena". (Although her existence is now dubious on acccount of our bad example.). Although he may be admissible on a temporary basis, for it remains that Athens has been shown foolish, and Socrates drives people insane. But Plato must renounce. Insofar as he renounced the republic in his Laws, Plato is excused, and the professors are blameworthy for failing to transmit this knowledge to their students. It is intellectually dishonest to transmit his hypotheses, because they are politically convenient, and to suppress his conclusions, because they are not.

Soren Kierkegaard and Jared Essig Redeemed by the Same

Virtue, Vice, and the Political Order

The Lyceum is worthy for it is public, but stupid insofar at it remains gymnastic, and without the Natural Peripatetics it has little to offer. And if Athens will insist upon absurdity and moral error, into exile we will go. And exile is made more attractive in that Macedonia is prepared to render philosophy the honor it is due. Call it a "political disease", or call it a "mental illness" if you are too proud to admit it, but Aristotle is justified. A virtuous monarch is to be preferred over a mob of vicious democrats, and this is not a divine right but merely a contingent social reality. If he will agree to make the kingship non-hereditary and constitutional, then we will accept his yoke and go into government service for Athen's new enemy. Therefore Sontag is also justified, for he alone among the faculty was willing stand by the Philosopher, during Aristotle's long, long exile. Moreover insofar as Jared is a lunatic and demonstrably intelligent, he is paradoxically sane. F.Sontag was a closeted lunatic himself, being a crypto-Jew, pressured by the faculty to assimilate to the solarian, neo-platonic cult that supports and tolerates each of their various eccentric doctrines, which when considered on whole, are mutually exclusive, incoherent, or absurd. This has the effect of driving them into despair, and thence idealistic ambition in support of the ruling political cult. Sontag was a victim of the College no less than young Essig was, and in consequence, we all suffer. Moreover, the Jew is justified, for his religion is philosophy, and he considers it law. Insofar is he is a natural philosopher and therefore a political subversive, Jared is justifiably paranoid. And moreover, Jared is an Aristotelian, and as Aristotle remains largely in exile, to everyone's loss, he is not unfortunate to join him there, for solitude is perhaps better than ignorant complicity. And he suggests that other students follow this example, drop out, and go public: for the Academy is corrupted by Sparta. Athens, though less an oligarch, is no less a Cretin. They are wise who do come out of her, lest they be defiled by her sins.