by Jared Essig © March 02 2023, last modified.

Charges: Criminal Mischief or Protected Speech?

During the late morning to early afternoon of July 17th 2020, during the racial justice protests and Antifa riots of that summer in Portland, a mural appeared stating "Do Justice Make Peace", on the anti-riot barrier, which was protecting the courthouse/police HQ/county jail complex confusingly named "the Justice center", from being occupied or burned down by the Leninist-Bolshevik mob that assembled nightly for that purpose, covering the building with incitements to murder, rape, and great bodily injury, after declaring that there was "no justice" and therefore there would be "no peace".

MCDA Protest Cases Data Dashboard

(Perhaps this happened because the court so unwisely to shares a building with the county jail and police headquaters, rendering the judiciary no longer independent, and justice dubious)

But it is for this alleged crime of humanitarian and pro-social mural art that Mr. Jared Essig was arrested and is now being tried in Multonomah County Circuit Court for a class A misdemeanor of "Criminal Mischief in the Second Degree", Case No. 20CR39057, by a district attorney who insists on defending the free speech and freedom of assembly of rioters, and who refuses to prosecute police who beat and kill unarmed suspects.

But the real nature of that criminal mischief that summer was not mural art calling for justice and peace. And everbody knows this, it seems, except the prosecutor, the forensic evaluator, and the judge whose courthouse almost burned down, who persist on denial in order to appease the mob or else maintain the illusion of their control, or perhaps both.

A broken window prevents the window from insulating against wind and cold.
A dumpster fire destroys both the dumpster and the air quality, along with any salvagable items in it.
A bolshevik mob on the portico and in the lobby prevents the courthouse from being used as a courthouse.
However, a mural on an anti-riot barrier does not damage the barrier as such, nor prevent its further use either as a barrier or as a canvas for other artistic uses or public service announcements, it doesn't do any permanent damage to the stone require special solvent chemicals to remove, as the other graffitti did.

In the actus reus of which Mr. Essig is accused, there is no incitement to riot. There is no permanent damage. Ergo, there is no actual crime of "mischief" that occurred, regardless of whether or not Mr. Essig did it. The actus reus under consideration by court is nothing but an act of political speech that is, in fact, protected by the 1st Ammendment to the constitution, which was included in the Bill of Rights expressly for this purpose.

And what exactly is "criminal mischief", we ask, if not unconstitutionally vague? Is it incitement to to personal violence or great bodily injury? Is it conspiracy to damage or steal, incitement to riot or insurrection? Is it sabotage of public property, or destruction of private property? All of these my client Mr. Essig denies. The state must bring an answerable charge, else motion to dismiss for failure to state a claim. The vagueness of this charge could allow the judiciary to effectively legislate ex post facto, which is unconstitutional. Therefore we already have cause for appeal, a priori on arrival.

It turns out (who knew?) that the Oregon Revised Statutes ignores all these ways in which "mischief" is ordinarily done by the average mischief maker, and merely defines the offense as a commission of $500 or less of property damage, regardless of the purpose or intent, and regardless of whether the fitness for its particular purpose, of said property, was or was not thereby impaired, which in this case it was not. The barrier remained an effective barrier after the mural art, in fact its effectiveness was enhanced by its increased respectability. If anything, the artist improved an undeveloped parcel within the public domain, and should be thanked. The indistinct vagueness of the statute leaves it inconsistent with natural language, common law, common sense, with the exigencies of the situation the civic artist was facing, which amounted to civil war from his perspective, and therefore will be inevtitably be inconsistent with the conscientious opinion of almost any jury. Almost noone reads the statutes anyway except for legal professionals who live in an alternate reality; the statutes aren't taught in schools, or available in the library, or on display in the courtroom, and the jury won't even know what they say until the judge tells them. Unless the judge succeeds in bamboozling them with big words, courtroom ritual, and the majestic decorum of a courthouse that nearly burned down, we can reasonably expect the jury to nullify.

The act of mural art for which Mr. Essig is accused, and was arrested in broad daylight while wearing plain clothes, was an act of political speech and done in the interest of the general welfare. All able bodied men are obliged in the administration of justice, and perhaps they needed to be reminded, given that elected officials were AWOL or else speechless.

It is alleged that Mr. Essig painted the words "Do Justice, Make Peace". Is that speech act more or less criminal than the other widespread graffiti calling for "kill cops", "F3&k the police", "burn this s#@t down"? On his published writings and media accounts, Mr. Essig goes to great lengths to denounce all this, even publishing a "styleguide for true propaganda" that gives tips on how to do graffiti abatement called "shut the fool down". And it has been syndicated at the site BastardsLivesMatter.org Why should he be scapegoated? Because the police are unable to make arrests of actual criminals? Because the prosecutor is unwilling to bring charges? Because the mob and its inciters were excercising their right to "free speech" and public assembly while calling for the murder and rape of public servants, and could not be disrupted until after 11pm, and even then only for "property crimes" or "interference with police officer" as if personal safety and life itself matters less?

Plea: Not Guilty, Lesser of Three Evils

Therefore Mr. Essig will himself present a legal defense of the mural artist, if no one else will. Vis a vis silence and complicity of the average bourgeois liberal, mural art was the lesser of two evils. Vis a vis the obscene and violent incitement of the mob, it was the lesser of three evils. Therefore the artist, whoever he was, is NOT GUILTY of criminal mischief. Moreover, as long as political speech is censured instead of protected in Portland Oregon, Mr. Essig will defend the artist without thereby incriminating himself. He neither admits nor denies the actus reus, and he preserves his 5th ammendment right against self-incrimination, and will do so without thereby impairing his ability to engage in the political speech which is so unjustly and unconstitutionally impaired by the state's prosecution of it.

Therefore he humbly asks the honorable judge to "Do Justice", by dismissng the case, and by furthermore rebuking the district attorney's office for bringing this tendentious and absurd waste of public resources and time, that does nothing to protect public safety, and morever relies on a perversion of natural law and common sense in order to do it. And thereby doing justly, we will also "Make Peace", and also exonerate the artist, whoever he was.

And if you will admit that the mural art did not constitute criminal incitement to riot, then why not charge him with sabotage or larceny instead, if the $5-$10 worth of toner paint required to destroy the artwork is a sum that the city is desperate to recover? The reason these moral rational charges are not being brought is for the simple reason that the artist did not sabotage the wall, damage its effectiveness as such, steal it, or prevent its use by others.
It remained a canvas for much graffiti that summer, and on days when humantarian and civic messages were not spray painted, the nightly mob inclined to use the surface for representations of dead pigs and guillotines, as is their custom. This has a effect of inculcating both a desensitization to violence as well as an intoxication with the thrill of it. Unless this is immediately abated AND REFUTED, this messaging will corrupt the minds of the youth, and a murder epidemic will become inevitable as the movement consumes itself in despair, criminality, and mutual exploitation. Therefore the message must be REFUTED, and not merely erase. How else does the city propose to erase it from our minds?

Forensic Diagnosis: Mass Civil Unrest and Mass Psychogenic Illness

The city is negligent, and therefore complicit with the toxic obscenity, which has engendered mass hysteria, ignorance, and intellectual and moral disease. How do you assess the pain and suffering caused by hours on end of chanting to "f&ck the police" and "kill the pigs"? How do you measure the intellectual darkness created by incessant chants of "all cops are bastards"? Their genealogies and birth defect are not what make cops (or anyone else for that matter), morally bad. Any authentic civil justice movement must ackowledge that bastards' lives, and those of other dis and differently abled people, also matter? (BastardsLivesMatter.org) Even if all cops are bad due to institutional racism and other injustices (and we ought to inquire about this), it is a demonstrable fact that some cops have two parents, and therefore not all of them are bastards. Conversely, having a legitimate birht from two married parents does not guarantee that a person, will be incorrupt in his professional ethics, whether that person does police work or something else. The charge of "bastard" is a vicious ad hominem fallacy, an irrelevancy at best, and it distracts from the necessary inquiry into the institutions of policing. The promotion of ignorance creates and intellectual and moral disease, and the city leaders ought to publicly refute this proposition, since it has been painted over public building thousands of times and chanted ad nauseum in the Portland plaza.

If Mr. Essig can teach this and demonstrate it - despite his alleged "mental illness", then why are the city leaders unable to do so? Is stupidity a mental illness, or is ignorant incompetence merely the "normal" here in Portland?

And how do you measure the distress of false shame and flatulent male hubris created by the perverse metaphorics of phallic power that are in constant shameful repitition, by DJ's pumping stip-hop and mumble trap music, neglecting all the conscious rap and R&B. This stuff degrades people as "bitches", regardless of their gender, on the misogynistic assumption that to be feminine is bad. But for a man to be "a dog" is somehow good? Its not! Shut the fool down. We've all heard dozens of times that black trans lives matter, but do black women's lives matter? Or black children? Black families matter, and ignorant denial of this is the disease.

By the way, FTP everybody. Can we free the people? Fornicating with the pigs is disgusting, and can we FTP from this perversion? Rape is a crime, and that includes butt rape. F#@king the police, or the mayor, or any other prisoner of war, would be a war crime. Even if revolution were warranted, this would not be. A protest that rationalizes rape by promoting a "diversity of tactics," is ipso facto, no longer a lawful assembly. Nor is it an authentic revolutionary movement; it is merely a counter-revolutionary criminal gang expandings its territory without making any systemic change.

Instead of declaring a riot 4 hours after this perverse (and illegal) incitement turns into actual sabotage, and instead of sending battalions of riot police to disperse them (which the police are physically unable to do), why doesn't the mayor and DA go out on the portico with their private detail security, sit down, listen the assembly, conduct their rage and ground it, address them and teach them these principles of justice? Since they are basically insane, they are not liable. But once you restore their sanity and competence by means of logic, evidence, and reliable testimony, perhaps they would eventually choose to disperse and make something of their lives and communities. And perhaps our elected officials woul learn something about what happens on the ground. Is it not the duty of a city attorney or a county judge to teach the law and uphold its principles before the general public? Where are all our legal professionals - Stuck in the law library somewhere, lost in the ORS? Where is the national lawyers guild - out in the streets helping the mob to burn it into ashes? Where is the interfaith clergy resistance - Still addicted to the lawless grace, homoerotic mysticism, and the paranoid grandiosity that comes from attempting to supercede the law, replace and forcibly assimilate the Jews, so christians can declare themselves the new "chosen people", and then can claim the Oregon Territory as the new "Promised Land" in fulfillment of their manifest destiny? Ignorance is the disease.

The entrance arch to Portland State University declares, "Let Knowledge Serve the City". So if the school is subsidized from the public treasury, let the professors come and tell us what they know about justice. Where are the aristotelian scholastics with their natural law theory - expelled from the university curriculum by the Bacon's religion of "modern science", and currently in exile at a Dominican monastery somewhere, and forced into absurd philsophic compromises by taking over the world in the Roman "universal" fashion? And where are the anti-aristotelian modernists who expelled them from the secular sphere - too busy denying the moral order, the natural law, the existence of God, the spiritual nature of humankind? Or else affirming metaphycial "Reason" through the german idealism of Kant, Hegel, and their heirs, while ignoring accountability for that system's political consequences in two world wars and the holocaust? Cowardly affirming the "wisdom" of agnosticism, the impossibility of certain moral knowledge, and the importance of hedonistic calculus, sexual experimentation, materialistism both democratic neoliberal on one hand and marxist on the other but always white supremacist through the worship of science and simultaneous neglect of it, and cash to pay for tuition in all this incoherent and absurd confusion? Knowledge, sadly, either does not exist in the university any more, or else it does not serve the city. Where is the scholar? Where is the sage? Where is the philosopher of this age? What is justice and how is it done? No one in Portland knows, because the academics are to busy suppressing it or distracting us with red herring, so that we don't discover justice and start disrupting the status quo. Ignorance is the disease today, as it has been in modern philosophy for few hundred years already. Eventually the pyramid scheme of graeco-roman imperialism will collapse. When exactly it does, and with how much pain, is anyone's guess, but this uprising is a signal.

When the thrill of mass hysteria meets the addictive illusion of power created by mob solidarity, the psychogenic illness is engendered by the unnatural pleasure of spiritual and political transcendence through violent revolution and toxic, malevolent stupidity. Unfortunately, it is addictive, and people seek the high. This confirms what musicians and religious hierophants have always known, and what running fanatics sometimes experience - that music and dance are the most powerful and deadly "drugs" known to man. It seems that the dancing epidemics of the middle ages have returned to afflict America, and although this bodes ill, one tangential benefit is that it refutes the atomistic materialism of the pharmacologists who have taken over the forensic mental "health" establishment on the deeply flawed and non-evidence based assumption that "mental illness" can be reduced to mere "chemical imbalance". As if the brain produces thoughts in basically the same way that kidneys produce urine, and as if our prior assumptions about true and false, and about right and wrong, had nothing to do with the thoughts that emerge.

The prosecutor calls Mr. Essig a criminal, but the mob called him a "cop" and a "bastard", even though he is neither. In what dollar amount do you calculate the psychic toll of being called a "cop" and "bacon", merely because a man opposes rioting? How much personal psychic injury results because of this constant drone that is tolerated and even defended by the city attorney, upon a tendentious misunderstanding of the 1st ammendment? The city attorney, mayor, and city council are culpable, and we will demand equitable relief. That is the actual criminal mischief that the city suffered - incitement to violent personal injury, rape, murder, terrorist threats, or "fighting words" used in dehumanizing of internal enemies. The first ammendment DOES NOT protect any of these, but the District Attorney does make public statements defending his policy tolerating it, because he wants to deny that its going on in order to justify his own passivity and incompetence in response. And perversely, the DA's office is now prosecuting a mural artist who writes "Do Justice, Make Peace", even though that is the very political speech protected by the first ammendment, which Portland's head lawyer ought to be protecting. This is a perversion of justice, and it demonstrates the truth of the maxim that "He who is kind to the cruel, will end in becoming cruel to the kind."

Treatment Plan for Grandiose Paranoia: More White Humilty, Less White Fragility

It suggests that the mass psychogenic illness has affected not only the mob, but also the minds of our civic leaders who try to maintain a zombie-like illusion of normality in conditions that are anything but. The DA needs to get over his fragility and learn to cope with his white privelege. And if this is too hard for him to figure out, he ought to stop prosecuting Mr. Essig and learn from him instead. Instrumentalize your priveleged education in the service of the common good. Revive your natural intellect from the stupor of aimless hedonism and meaningless pursuit of wealth and power (the white man's disease). Once your're able to start thinking clearly again, consider this.

Historic Circumstance: Protest, Riot, or Insurrection

The 1st ammendment does not protect incitement to insurrection against the government, and pockets of insurrection were indeed occuring. For example, chants of "Death to America" are generally considered insurrectionist, especially when they are followed by a siege of a federal building costing millions of dollars of damage, and especially when the chants occur at a "Palestinian Day of Rage" held on 7/1/2020 by local churches and activists in coordination with the PFLP, a foreign terrorist organization designated by the EU, the US State Department, and other governments in the Near East as well. Strange how this has escaped the notice of all our elected officials. Also strange that our activist organizations have adopted the palestinian strategy of riots which are designed to fail. Such riots are actually counter-revolutionary and ultimately self-destructive, and it starts with the teaching of hatred and the incitement to rage, while neglecting justice and peace. The failure of the anti-police movement in Portland could be predicted from this moment. Unless they renounce this, inevitably the mob would consume themselves in despair and self-indulgent escapism, descend into criminality and mutual exploitation. This is not how to conduct an insurrection or an independence movement.

Revolution, Natural Law, and Civic Duty

However, it should be noted that the Declaration of Independence makes clear that when the government becomes desructive of the rights of its citizens, it is their right, it is their duty to overthrow it, and fashion new guards for their future security." Therefore insurrection in and of itself, is not a crime in America. But it should not be undertaken for light and transient reasons, and due respect for the opinions of fellow man requires that they DECLARE THE CAUSE which impels them to the separation.

If you're going to mount or assist an insurrection, rage and malevolent stupidity are not adequate, and neither is the worship of rulers and dictators: you must have a plan based on the human rights and natural law. And with all due disrespect for the cowardice of Jefferson in failing to act on his well articulated anti-slavery and anti-racist principles, this lesson of his declaration is one that we could learn, and it is a lesson sadly lacking among both the revolutionaries and the civic leaders of today, and it is one that an publicly elected district lawyer can be reasonably expected to teach in times of legal crisis. If an average local houseless person like Mr. Essig can instrumentalize his own white privelege in times of great legal crisis, to visit the public library, do the research, acquire the intellectual resources and transmit them, then a well educated and financially endowed city lawyer can be reasonably expected to also do so also, in times of great legal crisis. DA Schmidt's failure to do so is cowardly, unjust, and culpable, and he ought to confess this, and issue the mural artist a hearty "thank you" for standing in during his absence.

Therefore the DA must either prosecute the demogogues for inciting insurrection (in addition to rebuking the malevolent stupidity), or else he must revolt with them and help them come up with a better plan. In either case, he ought to state a coherent rationale and strategy for so doing, based on the natural law and the rights of man (including woman and child), or else he is no lawyer, he is no leader, he is barely even a man, and he ought to be out of job.

Antidote following outbreak of Highly Contagious Psychic Illness

But if the DA is unwilling and unable to teach or uphold the rule of law, then he should not prosecute a private citizen for doing the job which he has abdictated. By pinning on the citizen-artist a false equivalence with the Leninist-Bolshevik mob, the DA tolerates and encourages this mob which the police are powerless to quell, and merely because the citizen used the anti-riot boarding of a civic building to accomplish what the DA could or would not: to teach the law, uphold the value of justice and peace, and protect the court/police headquarters/county jail building from getting burned down. Why was the district attorney not standing out there doing this job himself? In the time of I maintain that instead of burning it down, we ought to appoint better occupants for it. And regardless of whether Mr. Jared Essig is or is not the citizen mural artist who painted the design, "Do Justice, Make Peace", the artist ought to be commended, and his courageous act of political speech defended, because speaking truth and teaching the ethical principles of moral law IS THE ANTIDOTE AND PROPHYLACTIC to the illness engendered by the contempt for it. Whether or not he wrote the writing on the wall; the deed is not crime if what the writing said was true. The crime is the silent complicity of abdication of our elected leaders, who are effectively embezzling their own salaries from the public treasury, and have cost the city far more than the $5-$20 worth of gray paint used to cover a dozen square feet of anti-riot barrier. On nights when this message was painted, the courthouse was spared the graffitti of dead pigs and guillotines, and violent incitement. Which would you rather have?

Ethical Public Art as Prophylactic

Apparently the court has already agreed with Mr. Essig, and this is evident in the artwork painted around the perimeter of the new Multonomah County Circuit building on 1st and Taylor: the court adminstrator has figured out that PUBLIC ART is a PROPHYLACTIC against criminal mischeif, because a mob is unlikely to deface artwork that that states values consistent with what it believes. That is why the city ought to remove the statues, and recite the sayings of our dearly departed leaders instead of worhsipping their dead bodies. Also, use public art to teach the history, the ethics, and the law. The prosecutor ought to hire Mr. Essig as a public arts consultant, rather than prosecuting him, or else he ought to prosecute the court adminstrator for imitating his action and amplifying it. In fact, Mr. Essig has some suggestions on how the Courthouse art can be improved, and he promises to share them with you at a later date.

Let the state produce the photographic evidence. What is the "property damage¨, of which Mr. Essig is accused? Let the jury see it. Let the jury decide if that constitutes "criminal mischief", or whether it is a humanitarian pro-social prophylactic. The jury is not as stupid and ignorant as the prosecution. Mr. Essig has a right to be tried by a jury of his peers, and demands the constitutional exercise of this right. Let the jury decide whether it is or is nor a crime to single handedly stand down a vicious mob, and to incite the citizenry to justice and peace instead.

Citizenship in the Community

Any citizen who can and will abate this toxic propaganda, is entitled and justified in doing so, in the absence of city leaders and workers who can do it. If he must take the law into his own mouth, and pen, and paintbrush, in the absence of any moral authority from the city government that doesn´t merely show up in armed battalions, that citizen should take it up, and should and teach the moral law from natural philosophy, or as Dr. Bronner has so eloquently said, and as our soap bottles remind us, the all-one-God faith, and the moral ABC. Here is one -

murder is wrong. Black lives matter because human lives matter. The murder of public servants is wrong. Even if it were a just war that the mob were fighting, even if the police were truly enemies of the state, even then using a "diversity of tactics" that includes rape constitutes a war crime. And it amounts to a terrorist threat, and the city leaders who are silent, are complicit with this. Even worse, many of them encourage it. Since when is this protected under the first ammendment?

Whoever painted the mural which read "Do Justice, Make Peace" ought to be praised by the city rather than prosecuted. And the revised chant ends with this: (lets take to the streets and forget the police) Or would you rather be hearing the chant "No justice, no peace / lets take to the streets and f#@k the police¨?

Abdication and Complicity of the Government

Or would you rather be hearing the chant "No justice, no peace / lets take to the streets and f#@k the police¨?
Every demogogue in Portland was inciting this, following the semi-organized T.Raiford campaign, RCJ, the bolshevik-Leninists of "Antifa" (a Stalinist front in 30's germany), many of the black "kings and queens", and S.Iannarone's campaign was praising it. A notable exception to this trend was commissioner Hardesty, who in an open city council meeting, publicly interrupted and rebuked citizens who had threatened the mayor with butt rape during their public comment. To my knowledge, she is is the only civic leader who as been willing to do this. Thank you, commissioner Hardesty, real leaders will say this; it cannot be normalized by passive indifference. The rest of the commission, and the district attorney ought to stop the petulant whine and the demand for more resources, and instead follow her example. By the way, black lives do matter. I say that because I know my own life matters, and I believe yours does too, reader, whoever you are.

Stealing is wrong too, according the moral law, and property damage is a way of stealing from the public by denying the public the right to use a public resource. But the so-called ¨property damage" of which Mr. Essig is accused cost the city how much to abate? The defense demands an itemized list. Our estimate is this: 15 minutes of janitorial time. One paint roller, one twentieth of a bucket of paint. We estimate the property damage at $15-$45 dollars max, and without taking credit for this act of civil service, if the state has a counter-offer we may be willing to stipulate and settle this in civil court, since Mr Essig maintains that a good deed was done, and deserves to be defended, regardless of who did it. Since all that was ¨damaged" was anti-riot wood barriers, Mr. Essig might be willing to settle a civil case on the unknown culprits behalf, by paying damages, if the city would bring suit. Although he maintains that it was mural art that beautified the city, and not damage as the state alleges, he recognizes that beauty is in the eye of the beholder and that not everyone possesss the aesthetic intelligence to regard the message "Do Just, Make Peace¨, as a beautiful addition to our public art and a civically minded attempt at abating the flood of vicious and perverse graffitti that covered the plaza blocks of Portland during the "Antifa" hijacking of the BLM demonstrations, and the anti-police riots of 2020, which the city government was unable to abate or quell. Leaving us all swimming in a polluted lake of malevolent stupidity, which the beautiful murals around pioneer place, to which he also contributed, did only a little to refute. Nevertheless, Mr. Essig would be open to a civil compromise, and would consider the settlement a worthy investment in public art. How much property damage was done? How much money will it take to repair? And if the State does not wish to bring civil charges, the judge should dismiss the criminal action as tendentiously absurd, or else the jury will surely agree and bring you all to shame.

the judge should dismiss the criminal action as tendentious, unnecessary, not in the public interest, and a waste of professional services that could be better spent processing the actual criminal backlog of the court system.

State's Burden of Proof in its case against Humanitarian Mural Art and Freedom of Political Speech

If the state wishes to prove that the mischief was "criminal" as opposed to mere "civil mischief", a jury will need to be convinced that "incitement violence or incitement to riot" actually occured. It will be very hard for the state to prove this, given that all of Mr. Essigs known acts of mural art, which are recorded on his instagram at @jaredscribe, are specifically anti-riot messaging. This can also be seen on the new bastardslivesmatter.org which has recently appeared, adopting the "style guide for true propaganda", published on his own personal website, jaredscribe.com, where also his political manifestos can be read, along with his own eye-witness history of the protests and intifada during which he claims to have spread this propaganda through the medium of sharpie marker on cardboard. The prosecution will present this evidence, since it is publicly available, so there is no use or possibility of denying it. They will also present all the video footage of him defending the federal courthouse at night and getting beaten down by antifa mob, accused of terrible crimes in the twitter content stream such as "being a cop¨. Since it was not only the antifa livestreamers, but also Andy Ngo who has popularized these exploits, and since the entire national security apparatus and was deployed to aid and assist city government in this endeavor of defending the courthouse from getting burned down, there is no use in denying that Mr. Essig also participated in this effort. The intelligence agencies will co-operate, the local FBI will assist the PPB, and the te prosecution will present it as evidence, and we will stipulate. And if they are unable to do this, then they are wasting the public money and are culpable for ten thousand times as much "property damage" as Mr. Essig is allegedly culpable for. They tried to quell the riots with force, he tried to quell the riots with logic, discourse, and self-evident facts of nature and truths of moral law. The photographic evidence that the state will provide, along with much more that is available to internet sleuths online, will demonstrate clearly that the messaging for which he has undeniably claimed credit, is specifically anti-riot messaging. Mr. Essig strongly holds that rioting is both counter-revolutionary and anti-liberal, since riots are designed to fail. Therefore he feels it a civic duty to spread anti-riot propaganda while also doing artwork promoting human liberation and personal dignity for all the oppressed. He intends to continue this work, and offers to donate his services in volunteering for the gratis if they will provide the paint and the surface to paint it on.

Civil Service is not Criminal Mischief

The protestors will eventually "wake up" to the fact that not all police are bastards, and that this is a demonstrable fact. The will wake up to the fact that some non-bastards are bad people, and it can be assumed that at least some if not all police are in this category, and the mob is entitled to point this out. Also some bastards are good people, and they object to the comparison with police. It is in this manner of logic and argument that Mr. Essig suceeded in single-handely dispersing the mob, whereas all the city's cop cruisers and all the city's men, simply could not, and nor can they put our Portland back together again. That is why Mr. Essig's super-normal moral and aesthetic intelligence is needed in this city. And it is why the city should retain his services as a consultant on public art.

Crucially, the mural art of which he is been accused did not carry any Incitement to violence, therefore does not constitute "criminal mischief". What it said was "Do Justice, Make Peace". Should this not be called "civic service" instead of "criminal mischief"? Given the circumstances of which we are all aware (millions of dollars worth of actual property damage in unabateable anti-police riots) why should this action not be called a "good deed?" The state has a high burden of proof to meet in the mind of a jury who, unlike tendentious legal professionals, understand very clearly that the law prohibiting murder and rape are written on the heart of man, in the conscience that was given to him by God the creator, long before it was every enacted into the Oregon Revised Statutes, and independently of what they actually say, which no one knows because no one reads them or teaches them, apparently not even the police.

It has been alleged that Mr. Essig's appeal to natural law over and above the statute, constitutes an "unsound legal argument", suggesting that he is incompetent to "aid and assist" his public defender, who is seeking to have him admitted into an outpatient treatment program in lieu of punishment for the good dead of which he is allegedly guilty.

But how is Mr. Essig's legal argument less sound than the courthouse that he had to protect from being burned down? How is his foundation less sound than a court that has presided over a massive increase in both property crime and murder, and a district attorney's office decimated by attrition, and an elected DA who recently published in the newspaper of record a frank admission of failure and petulant whine for more public resources devoted to his office? More money is not a substitute for coherent strategy and sound legal argument.

Moreover, Criminal mischief, did in fact, obviously, occur. And something should probably be done. It occured among the tens of thousands of graffitied incitements to kill and rape, which the police unable to prevent, the custodians were unable to abate, and the state is now unable to prosecute, because almost none of the inciters were arrested. What should a justice-working and peace working mural artist should be scapegoated for a crime that others committed - merely to satisfy the states desire for retribution against some poor scapegoat? Why should the state be allowed to punish this innocent man, merely to make a pathetic pretense at covering up its own negligence, incompetence, and lack of moral foundation? The state has a very difficult case to prove before a jury, irregardless of what the Oregon Revised Statutes say, which nobody knows, nobody reads, and is nowhere to be found outside of obscure law libraries that nobody visits except legal professional who live in an alternate reality. Common law, deriving from natural law, is the law of the land, regardless of the hubristic delusions floating around in the mind of the legal professors and the incompetent and negligent district attorneys office. And if the statutes do not agree with the natural law, which unlike the statute is commmonly known and generally accepted, then the jury will see to it that the statutes are nullified.

And if the prosecutor, judge, and forensic evaluators find this prospect to be insulting to their professional qualification and legal education, then they ought to consider wether the populace should be insulted in equal and opposite fashion by the refusal of the "professionals" to teach the law, to uphold the law, to value the morals and ethics that inform it, or to admit the principles of justice and mercy whence it naturally derives. Is that not an insult? And the forensic evaluator and judge have dared to call me "incompetent" for for the mere act of disssent? How dare they? If the government rejects the law of nature, and of natures God, and denies the self-evident truths the derive therefrom, then the government has become destructive of the rights of the people, and it is the people's right and their duty to remove such government from power and appoint new guards for their future security and general welfare. Jury nullification is one of the ways that this can occur, and this is why the right to a trial by a jury of ones peers is enshrined in the US Constitution, with T.Jefferson regarding it as even more fundamental than the right to vote. We concur, and we reasonably expect that the jury will agree.

I demand a trial by a jury of my peers, and they will decide whether or not your courthouse itself has a more sound legal foundation than my arguement.

Arrest of Mr. Jared Essig

Apart from the actus reus - which we have already determined was not a crime, let us consider the arrest: my client on the other hand, Jared Essig, was arrested in broad daylight while in plain clothes.
The event at which he was arrested was a "blue lives matter" gathering in the late morning, and he was part of a small counter-demonstration that approached the "blue lives matter" group to ask them, if they would admit that "black lives matter". They would not. At this rally, Mr. Essig claims to have successful de-escalated an antifascist protestor who was disruptively trying to start a confrontation with an armed man, acccusing him of making threats (which he did not do), and Mr. Essig defended the mans right to bear arms in self-defense and kept the two apart from each other so that no misunderstanding could occur. Apart from this, no fighting words were exchanged (which is unusual in portland rallies), and no violent confrontation between the two relatively small groups. After the counter-demonstrators moved on to city hall, the message "Do Justice, Make Peace" was painted on the anti-riot boarding of the "Justice center", and shortly thereafter two police officers approached Mr. Essig while was alone in Shrunk amphitheater, grabbed him by the arms without declaring a cause, handcuffed him, and walked him to their police cruisers which were by city hall, where the "black lives matter" rally was gathered and about to disperse. But instead of sitting him on the curb and questioning him, the simply tried to force him into the cruiser, at which point Mr. Essig while in handcuffs, justifiably resisted what he suddenly perceived as a "kidnapping": no cause had been given for his arrest and the police had not charged him with any offense or had any verbal contact with him at all. This was a very strange encounter, that Mr. Essig felt violated his constitutional right of habeas corpus - the police have no right to arrest a person without cause or hold him in custody without bringing charges. After a minute of struggle, and the futile attempt of a young woman to de-arrest him by annoying the police officer with something that appeared to be a rolled-up newspaper or maybe a yoga mat accompanied by high-pitched shrieking, the police moved Mr. Essig into the back of the cruiser. A video of this encounter is available somewhere on social media.

Conclusion and Competence

The competence to understand the ethical and legal issues here, and to argue his case has been demonstrated by this very document outlining his argument. It is prima facie evidence that his mind and intellect are intact, and that attempts to paint him as "mentally ill" are a refusal to account for the post-traumatic stress that he and anyone in his position would suffer. Worse, he attempts to dismiss his legal argument as a sign of "incompetence" due to "hyperverbalism", is a mere refusal to listen and a pathologization of dissent - a well known tactic of totalitarian governments who send their dissidents to the gulag or the state hospital for "re-education". It is a recourse unworthy of being dignified by an American jurist. Sadly, it is becoming systemic in a system where afflicted people are systematically incarcerated for crimes against "public order", and denied their right to refuse medication. Whatever post-traumatic stress Mr. Essig is under, he is able to overcome it sufficiently to bear witness in court and to do the work of assisting in the administration of justice, in which all men are commanded.

The prosecutor, forensic evalutor, and possibly even his own public defender have refused to understand the ethical issues at stake here, or the historical circumstances, or to admit the importance of these. Instead, they tendentiously rely on an obscure legal technicality in order to avoid the moral and ethical issues at stake, and scapegoat Mr. Essig while covering up for their own incompetence at understanding and applying the law in the interest of justice and public safety. Parallel to the city council's failure to prevent or quell the riots or decrease crime, which has only increased in the interim since then, most likely due to the incoherent strategy and their inverted priorities that are on display here in full support of systemic injustice in the form of medicalized tyranny over the lives of the poor, the afflicted, ethnic minorities, and political dissidents, done probably in the interest of institutional racism and "scientific" eugenics. Mr. Essig, like many other houseless and formerly incarcerated people, has every reason to be "service resistant". You should expect the service resistance and the houselessness crisis to become worse, the harder you push these coercive treatements.

The message painted on the anti-riot boarding, allegedly by myself, Jared Essig who is writing this discourse, was "Do Justice, Make Peace". This was "POLITICAL SPEECH", that directly interdicted the dominant discourse of widespread rioting, looting, and incitement to murder, rape, and great bodily injury, with which he was surrounded. The artist might well have been doing grass-roots abatement and preventative counter-measures. If Mr. Essig was indeed the artist, as the prosecution alleges, his infinitely the lesser of at least two evils, and maybe even three or more.

The city and state ought to refocus their efforts on arresting and prosecuting actual criminals, rather than pursuing this quixotic case against whomever painted this, probably a local good samaritan, perhaps a semi-nomadic ethno-religious minority, perhaps even someone who has a personal stake in the outcome of this tendentious civil war between between white ¨pride" and prejudice on the one side and bolshevik-leninist terrorism on the other, in which both sides are demonstrably in the wrong to any sane outside observer, both upstaging the necessary messages that black and indigenous lives do, in fact matter, and that police must be held accountable to the same laws they enforce, and the jury can be expected to agree. Mr. Essig furthermore asserts that Asiatic lives matter, including Gypsies and Jews.

This is the only piece of sound moral reasoning that has emerged from the prosecutor, the judge, the forensic evaluator, and from his own public defender whose primary goal seems to be a humiliating compromise, not guilty by reason of insanity, or some other way of avoiding a trial.

Moreover, Mr. Essig is the only one who can competently argue this, because he appears to be the only one in the legal defense community, who truly believes it.

Therefore we ask the judge to dismiss the finding of "incompetence", and allow the trial to proceed. Without admitting or denying the allegations, Mr. Essig retains his 5th ammendment right to avoid self-incrimination, while simultaneously pleading "Not guilty" - because the action of which he is alleged guilty, was the lesser of two evils. Given the circumstance, mural art was not a crime. Mr. Essig insists on defending the 1st ammendment right of the unnamed mural artist to engage in political speech. It is especially important to defend this right, when it is used for such an important message, in such a time as this.